3 ms·
I believe I did that. Regarding that guideline, are commenters supposed to follow a similar guideline in how to interpret the source material, or are they free
by eesmith 8y ago
I believe I did that.
Regarding that guideline, are commenters supposed to follow a similar guideline in how to interpret the source material, or are they free to make a weaker interpretation that is easier to criticize?
Because one of my objections was how the article said that sedation was used on someone both handcuffed and strapped down, while the OP gave examples where someone handcuffed was sedated, and someone strapped down was sedated, but not both. That seems criticizing a weaker topic than what the article described.
Similarly the article presented a case where someone was both physically restrained and chemically sedated, while the OP described chemical sedation as an alternative to physical restraint. That too feels like criticizing a weaker topic than what the article described.
JshWright, to whom I replied, in another branch of this thread kindly commented "I think your comment is thoughtful and contributes meaningfully to the conversation."
- JshWright 8y ago> while the OP gave examples where someone handcuffed was sedated, and someone strapped down was sedated, but not both Ah, I think that's a case where my existing context led to a lack of clarity... If someone is "strapped" to the stretcher (i.e. not just the usual seatbelts), then their wrists are restrained (either in handcuffs, or using "soft restraints" to the side rails of the stretcher). The reality is, a stretcher is not designed to serve as an anchor for restraints, and someone who continues to fight over the course of a 20-30 minute transport will eventually work themselves free (at least enough to start kicking). Similarly, chemical restraint is always preceded by physical restraint. It's only when physical restraint isn't working (i.e. someone is fighting hard enough that there's a risk of injury) that chemical restraint is employed. It's in those cases that chemical restraint is safer (obviously continuing to wrestle with someone is more dangerous for everyone involved).
- eesmith 8y agoThank you for the additional clarifications.