4 ms·
> The SEC has consistently seen utility tokens as securities. The workaround, so far unproven in court, is the SAFT (simple agreement for future tokens). The i
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> The SEC has consistently seen utility tokens as securities. The workaround, so far unproven in court, is the SAFT (simple agreement for future tokens).
The issue with all of this is that people are trying to fit a new technology into a series of boxes when it doesn't fit into any of them.
The problem cryptocurrencies aim to solve looks like this. I have a hardcopy of a book that I've finished reading and I'm prepared to sell it so I can use the money to buy a copy of another book. I am not keen on the efficiency of the barter system, so what I need is currency that allows me to sell the book I have and then buy the book I want.
But currency isn't a security. The rules for securities are much more strict, because you have to worry about people defrauding investors and engaging in stock price manipulations etc. In the normal everyday currency transaction where I exchange my book for a $20 bill and then go somewhere else and exchange my $20 bill for a book, there is never any paperwork for me to fill out. I don't have to give anyone my name or anything else to allow them to compile a database of which books I read or which social clubs I patronize or what kind of contraceptives I use.
The rules for digital credit transactions are also strict, because they were designed for credit transactions, where you have to worry about someone buying something on credit and then not paying, or taking out credit in someone else's name.
What's really needed is a digital version of cash. But there is no law designed for digital cash, so people keep trying to squeeze things that aim to serve that purpose into one box or another when the rules were clearly designed for something else.
What we need is for the law to more explicitly allow the internet to work like the real world.
- cortesoft 8y agoRight, but the article is talking about ICOs, not cryptocoins in general.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoBut once there is an ICO then whatever it is it continues to be, right? It obviously impacts the initial value of a coin if it can't practically be used as currency because future trades have to be treated as a regulated securities instrument.
- lmm 8y agoIf someone issued a physical banknote for their book-trading club idea and a bunch of those changed hands at speculative prices while the book-trading club didn't even exist, you bet the SEC would regulate it as a security. This has nothing to do with internet versus real world.
- s73v3r_ 8y ago"The issue with all of this is that people are trying to fit a new technology into a series of boxes when it doesn't fit into any of them." No, I think it's more that it does fit into those boxes, but those with interests in the technology desperately want to think it doesn't. "What we need is for the law to more explicitly allow the internet to work like the real world." Why?