5 ms·
Because we must assume black people are intrinsically just as capable as white people, the goal must be to drive that disparity to zero. Must we? There's anoth
by userbinator 8y ago
Because we must assume black people are intrinsically just as capable as white people, the goal must be to drive that disparity to zero.
Must we? There's another comment here about no one seeming too bothered that the NBA doesn't contain very many Asians. Is it already too racist to believe that there are certainly trends in race, and that everyone is different and should be considered on their individual merits alone?
As a (Asian) friend once remarked, "raise the bar on us and we just jump higher. Lower the bar on the Blacks and they try even less, because they know they don't have to do as much."
Indeed, it seems all that making it harder for Asians and easier for Blacks has done is pushed the Asians harder to achieve even more, which certainly isn't helping equality much. A pretty good demonstration of the law of unintended consequences.
- adamsea 8y agoIf you take the time to read real history written by highly educated and thoughtful scholars (as opposed to bs pseudo intellectual history) then yes. Just think about the racist stereotypes held by Americans towards Chinese and Japanese people during and prior to WWII. Those stereotypes were not of the successful violin playing overachiever, I can promise you that. Thus, for anyone willing to look in the mirror, all sorts of implicit biases and stereotypes or prejudices - racial or otherwise - must be called into question if you want to live a life of intellectual honesty with oneself.
- gspetr 8y agoA "devil's advocate" can refute that by either narrowing or broadening the scope to great individuals/civilizations. When was the last time you heard about african Nobel prize winners? Or african artists/composers? African philosophers or generals? The asians have Confucius, Sun Tzu, etc. speak for them. Whom do the africans have?
- unclebucknasty 8y agoYou asked "when was the last time..." for Africans as if you were referring to recent history, then went back to Confucius and Sun Tzu for Asians? That's pretty funny. So, are you including Ancient Egypt for Africa or only later? Because, as you know, so much is derivative of that civilization. Otherwise, slightly more recently, do Shaka Zulu, Ras Mengesha Yohannes, and Tariq ibn Ziyad, count for generals? How about Mandela, Soyinka, and Tutu for Nobel prize winners? And, of course, for more fun we can reference other categories of "achievement", the value of which is culture-specific, then ask which other cultures have matched those "achievements".
- gspetr 8y ago> That's pretty funny. So, are you including Ancient Egypt for Africa or only later? Asians still have advanced countries, on par with the biggest and largest white majority countries, do they not? Modern Egypt is a backwards country that is not even in top 100 countries by GDP, HDI, or whatever combination of meaningful metrics to describe a country's civilization level you might choose. Peace prize is meaningless since Arafat and Obama got one too. Literature prize is better (though nowhere near as good as hard sciences). In Soyinka's case though, you don't have much of a leg to stand on, because he was educated in a British dominion and moved to the UK at the still tender age of 20. > do Shaka Zulu, Ras Mengesha Yohannes, and Tariq ibn Ziyad, count for generals? No. The first two were either backwards (Shaka argued for strategies that were essentially a zerg rush vs firearms) or woefully unequipped by the standards of the time. Indeed, Shaka's most known victory featured 10:1 numerical superiority. It was also a pyrrhic victory in the grand scheme of things, as the British sent competent officers later and steamrolled the Zulu. As for Ziyad, few things are known about him and where's his "Art of War" or "On War"?
- siosonel 8y agoWe must. Asians have not been systematically denied entry to the NBA for hundreds of years. I do not deny that there are ethnic differences or cultural priorities. But if a group of people has been systematically told for a very long time that they cannot achieve anything beyond being a slave, then that oppressed group would probably not bother to engage in technical or scientific pursuits, nor would they have time to pursue higher education because they were not allowed to do so. Think about that: a group of people have been systematically given a chance to prove themselves, while another group was systematically prevented from doing the same. It's a systemic issue that requires a comprehensive solution. It must start with assuming the very assumption that you are questioning, since how else could start from a clean slate? (1. And no, race blindness is not starting from a clean slate, it's denying the systematically-imposed disadvantages that already exists. 2. Your examples posing asians against blacks and asians rub me the wrong way, a bit like race baiting although I don't know you enough or the tone of your explanations to say for sure.)
- fraudsyndrome 8y ago> Asians have not been systematically denied entry to the NBA for hundreds of years. I find this comment goes deeper when I followed Jeremy Lin's progression into the NBA. I suggest anyone who is interested in your comment should read too. Lin wasn't systematically denied entry, but the kind of stuff he faced and endured based on his race - which was admitted to by a coach, was pretty bad. And I feel this type of behavior that he faced - when your race is in the minority of the place you're trying to get to/be at - can be applied elsewhere. Like Black people thinking that others might think that they got there based on affirmative action and not by merit, or Asian Americans thinking that others think there are "too many Asians" here or the likes. In some situations, minorities aren't being outright denied by law/whathaveyou but they are put in potentially "hostile" environments where they might feel like they don't belong, which can be akin to being denied socially.
- siosonel 8y agoI agree Jeremy Lin's experience in the NBA was not smooth with regards to acceptance, maybe even now. I'm an Asian, and I've experienced social questioning/shocks that you mention. Having said that, I still hope that the difference in priority and importance is obvious between: (a) correcting the impacts of hundreds of years of systematic outright denial of opportunity in all aspects of life, and (b) a top school's rejection of an applicant who do not belong to an under-represented group and who will likely get admitted in another top school or another very good school.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kryogen1c 8y agoCouldn't agree more. In what reality is lowering standards a way of raising quality? How would it help a black person to be affirmative actioned into a school their admittance evaluation indicates they could not succeed at? I guess affirmative action is only for black kids who barely don't meet the requirements?
- candiodari 8y agoWho decides on society ? Priests or tests ? That's the choice here. So how are we "raising quality" ? Easy: this is raising quality in this way. We have collectively decided what quality is (ie. "perfect" equality). We have also extensive data that reality ... just doesn't match our quality metric (different subgroups in society are ... different. In pretty much every factor you might use. Including of course in IQ, in how much they work, how they dress, who they marry, in height (which might matter to the NBA), in width, in health, in skin tone, in religion ... So we've decided on morality, and we've found that reality doesn't match morality ... (and we're conclusively ignoring that morality is nothing but a fashion-like set of ideas that moves around randomly even within supposedly constant religions, so you can imagine just how random and inaccurate it'll be under Hollywood's/Reality/outrage media/breitbart's/... guidance) So we've gone the way of the flat earthers. Reality doesn't matter our opinion of what is just so we are going to ... (take a wild guess) Cheat and fake and force and ... until reality matches our sense of justice. Now I get it. It's really sad that reality just isn't fair. Really sad. Another little tidbit is that humans, individuals, also just aren't fair. Giving specific humans the right, even the duty, to correct the unfairness of reality therefore merely results ... in abuse of that system. That system is especially vulnerable because it must be designed so that administrators cheat, after all, that's exactly what a racial quota does : it cheats "on behalf of the just cause X". Needless to say, I consider cheating putting the worse student ahead of the better student. If you think individual administrators aren't going to use this to cheat on behalf of their family, ideological side, race, religion, ... you just haven't been paying attention. Of course the system itself is highly selective. Observant Christians, for instance, are severely underrepresented at universities. That's apparently not worthy of affirmative action. Why ? Because there's no public outrage on this subject (besides observant Christians will just think they need to work harder). Palestinians are actually overrepresented at universities. Ok, also not a problem apparently. Too few self-described African-Americans ? Huge problem. Not that anybody can even state a consistent vision of what the goal is. The problem lies in which groups have the right to have perfect representation, because for obvious reasons, that can't be all possible groups. Imho that, in itself is discrimination. Very postmodern, of course. You can't expect anyone to pin down the policy ... that by itself is racism. (of course the real problem is that a pinned down policy, whatever it is, would open them up to criticism) In a sense this is about who gets to decide what is the top of society : performance/"reality" ... or the priest class. Affirmative action, of course, is a firm choice for the priest class (weak counter: but it's not ! "We're atheist". Needless to say, today's priest class isn't even the first atheist priest class. See how society worked in ancient Athens, or even the Roman Republic. Priests decided outcomes, but "not on the basis of religion, as there were no gods invoked (except in jest in the Roman case). Or you could invoke various communist societies that also were very strongly classist, with atheists "priests" essentially selecting outcomes for individuals "to make things fair" (hah !)) And why ? Because "reality" is racist (that, of course, is the reason evolution works, but let's just ignore that). But of course, THIS version of morality is the be-all end-all final version of morality that is going to treat everyone fairly ! Every last other one is/was an abomination, but THIS TIME .... this time we got it right, and we're going to be destroying people's lives with no recourse for them at all because THIS TIME we know what's right ! Let's rejoice in our just outcomes ! Let's call it the "final solution". (that last sentence is a joke, as that term served as Nazi Germany's euphemism for the holocaust)
- Latteland 8y agoYes, assuming intellectual trends based on race is a horrible idea. I can't accept that it does anything but lead to justification for racism. to be in the nba, you have to be really tall. you might benefit from there being less opportunities than athletics for your peers, so you'll try harder. seeing others that a similar succeeding might motivate you more. these could be things that help asians see they can succeed, but at the same time shows blacks that the nba is a more likely opportunity than traditional college (whether its true or not).
- mdimec4 8y agohttps://www.targetmap.com/viewer.aspx?reportId=36156 https://www.targetmap.com/viewer.aspx?reportId=36156
- unclebucknasty 8y agoThe thing is I know you mean well, and we need more people who are willing to express opinions like this so there can be honest dialogue. Then, people like me can come along and say "that is just so terribly misguided and simplistic"! First, to throw out comparisons between two "groups" with completely different histories results in facile conclusions and fallacious attributions of causation (i.e. just like yours). Second, the idea that African Americans or Asians each represent a homegeneous group is just incorrect. Third, you don't account for billions of impoverished Asians who have not cleared that high-bar. Indeed, those who make it to Western nations like the U.S. are exceptional by definition. Likewise, you talk about blacks needing a higher bar to clear as if slavery, Jim Crow, ongoing biases, misconceptions (i.e. like yours here) and outright discrimination aren't high enough. Indeed, by any reasonable acknowledgement of history, African Americans should be extinct. Yet, many are actually thriving. That is self-determination and "bar-clearing" that rivals or exceeds just about anything you can find in this country. Remember, we're only ~150 years outside of slavery. There are people alive today whose lifespans overlap with those of formerly enslaved family members. And, of course, there are many alive today who lived through Jim Crow--that is codified discrimination. And, implicit and explicit biases are still rampant. Does that give you any sense of irony for suggesting that African Americans simply need a higher bar to clear? Please stop comparing the African Americans who are struggling most with the exceptional Asians (or others) who have made it to American shores. Please expand your understanding of the real challenges that African Americans have historically faced and continue to face and reckon with the astounding achievements they have realized in spite of this.