4 ms·
> By enforcing racial quotas, Harvard and other institutions are actively cementing race as an important factor in our society That's not really accurate. If y
by Alex3917 8y ago
> By enforcing racial quotas, Harvard and other institutions are actively cementing race as an important factor in our society
That's not really accurate. If you look at the Coleman report, the main study that was done in the run up to school desegregation and forced busing, it showed a bunch of negative impacts to changing the racial balance of institutions too quickly. That research was largely ignored, which in part lead to white flight, inner city gangs, and a bunch of other issues we still haven't really recovered from to this day.
Contrast this to the integration of gays in the military, which was done over a few years rather than all at once and went much more smoothly -- you didn't see any major issues or society-wide backlash as a result.
The point is that policies that ignore race often make racial issues more salient and pronounced as a result, rather than leading to a society where race isn't a factor or whatever. That's not to say that Harvard isn't doing anything wrong, but it's naive to assume that ignoring race is going to lead to some sort of post racial society.
C.f.: http://pages.jh.edu/jhumag/0400web/18.html http://pages.jh.edu/jhumag/0400web/18.html
It's actually still one of the biggest studies ever done and probably that ever will be done, because it was conducted before they really understood the math behind representative samples and statistical significance, so it had way more participants than were actually needed.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Alex3917 8y ago> how did forced busing lead to inner-city gangs? White students (the vast majority) targeted the black students, who then formed gangs to protect themselves. There is a good multi-decade ethnography of the effects of various changes in public policy and society on one particular high school here: https://www.amazon.com/World-We-Created-Hamilton-High/dp/067496201X https://www.amazon.com/World-We-Created-Hamilton-High/dp/067... The high school is anonymized, but iirc it's somewhere in Syracuse, NY. Note that (at least afaik) that's not directly where our modern national-scale gangs come from, although White flight and the collapse of cities surely did contribute there also.
- adrianratnapala 8y agoRight or wrong, it is difficult to see how forced busing counts among "policies that ignore race".
- KKKKkkkk1 8y agoGays always served in the US military. The introduction of don't ask don't tell had nothing to do with integrating them into the military, and everything with keeping them in the closet.