4 ms·
The problem with that approach is that you can end up begging the question and not realizing that your proposed answers start to deviate wildly from evidence.
by jcranmer 8y ago
The problem with that approach is that you can end up begging the question and not realizing that your proposed answers start to deviate wildly from evidence.
For Jared Diamond, the answer to the question of European domination is solely that Eurasia won the agricultural jackpot [1] and the Americas lost it, and anything that happened in the intervening 10,000 years doesn't factor into it. But... the Americas won the agricultural jackpot (there's a reason why potatoes became a staple crop in much of the world). And the European conquest of the Americas was anything but preordained: the Spanish only conquered Tenochtitlan (which was a larger city, it should be noted, than likely any of the Spanish had ever seen before) with the help of their 20,000 Tlaxcala allies.
[1] The astute will notice that there's a related question that Diamond 100% completely ignores... why didn't China dominate?
- o_____________o 8y ago> For Jared Diamond, the answer to the question of European domination is solely that Eurasia won the agricultural jackpot This is oversimplified to the point of either being disingenuous or misinformed, and China was discussed in the book. There are valid issues with the work, including environmental determinism[1], but it was a wide ranging pop sci book and as such has many surfaces and incentives for attack. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_determinism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_determinism
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> including environmental determinism[1] Why is this considered an issue? Is there a good discussion of this that you could recommend?
- michaelt 8y agohttps://www.livinganthropologically.com/archaeology/guns-germs-and-steel-jared-diamond/ https://www.livinganthropologically.com/archaeology/guns-ger... I argue that although Diamond makes interesting points, his work from Guns Germs and Steel to Collapse is a distorting disservice to the real historical record. Diamond claims that the differential success of the world’s nations is due to the accidents of agriculture, except when societies “choose to fail.” This claim does not withstand scrutiny. [...] Unfortunately his story-telling abilities are so compelling that he has seduced a generation of college-educated readers.
- mehwoot 8y ago100% completely ignores... why didn't China dominate? Have you even read the book? It's mentioned and he gives possible reasons for it, even though it isn't the focus of the book.
- javajosh 8y agoI read the book, a very long time ago, but my understanding is that China was never interested in expansion, culturally. China itself was a vast, insular monarchy for thousands of years, protected by the Himalayas to the west, an ocean to the east and south, and vast steppes to the north. The Chinese, culturally, were convinced of their innate superiority (like most cultures!) and only wanted to perfect their kingdom, not grow it. European culture, on the other hand, was not homogenous and the in-fighting between "white" nations forced each one to find advantage anywhere they could find it, including overseas, and the valuable raw-materials a globe-spanning empire can give the homeland. The technical difficulties of running large navies, building ships, lead to lots of engineering advances. So, I guess if China hadn't been unified, and had been more vulnerable, parts of it would also have been forced to seek advantage in trade, and history would have been a very different story.
- ForRealsies 8y agoNot a history major, but wasn't Northern China conquered by foreign invaders again and again? It was anything but pleasant.
- vinceguidry 8y agoChina did dominate. Everybody that invaded China, became Chinese. It's a massive success story. If you're asking why it didn't colonize, that answer can also come down to geography. It's landmass was so good, it literally had no need for colonization. Once Europe chopped down its forests and got everything it could out of mines, it had a surplus of people that craved more things, this drove it to expand outwards. China's just big and resourceful enough to provide. Once it collapsed into one big polity, something made necessary by lack of natural barriers like in Europe preventing individual nations from being able to protect themselves, everybody could work together to build China. Europe's geography just wasn't as good. Good enough to get to colonization, but not good enough to avoid the need to. You see this happening now in the US, which boasts the second best geography in the world after China. We had a few colonies, but really, our landmass provides us with everything we need. It just wasn't good enough without European horses.
- pvaldes 8y ago> the Americas won the agricultural jackpot I Don't think so. The trouble with America was that the people wiped most big fauna before doing any serious domestication attempts. America always lacked force-power for agriculture by lacking suitable animals. Deer and antelopes are un-trainable and intractable, specially when in heat; big cats pose a lot of problems; bears are too solitary and individualistic and pronghorn were skittish, designed to run fast and go away, not easy to confine in small spaces. And Lamas, almost the only big animals available suitable to domestication, are still too small and lack power to help with a plow. Maybe glyptodonts would made marvelous and valuable domestic animals. We'll never know. The old world instead had the horse and the bull, that made an huge success in agriculture. Small details like egyptians having a small friendly carnivore around made a huge difference in an economy based on grain. And the carp recycling agriculture debris and the chicken where a blessing for China also.