4 ms·
> It’s not about “scarcity”. Renting for physical goods has scarcity involved. To make a new item, you have constant expenses, thus when you rent it, avoiding
by shmerl 8y ago
> It’s not about “scarcity”.
Renting for physical goods has scarcity involved. To make a new item, you have constant expenses, thus when you rent it, avoiding that expense allows lower price.
With digital goods, you have fixed expense, which after it's paid off has no constant expense involved. So the above renting logic isn't applicable. The remaining reason for renting to be cheaper is artificial, i.e. its limited nature, that prevents you from making backups and etc. That crippling of the product makes it cheaper, but the whole crippling is artificial to begin with.
> How much would you be willing to pay for all the content you can get on Netflix, Hulu, etc.
Depending on the film, may be different prices. Definitely more for something I'd watch more than once.
- scarface74 8y agoDoes that mean every single software as a service company business model is invalid?
- shmerl 8y ago> Does that mean every single software as a service company business model is invalid? I'm OK with someone offering digital renting, if there is an option to buy the same thing (though I wouldn't use it if it has DRM). I'm not OK with it, if renting only is mandated. Software as a service isn't exactly the same case as buying books, films, music, games and etc. For instance Web search is software as a service and I'm OK with it running remotely (though decentralized search is a way to improve it in theory). But when I listen to music and the like, I want to have a backup of it and run and use it on any device I want, and not on what some DRM authorized it for on condition of some existing account.
- scarface74 8y agoHow is Netflix, Hulu, etc. not the same? You pay $10.99 a month and get unlimited access to an entire library of content. What device that you own can’t play Spotify music?
- shmerl 8y agoAs I explained above, their problem is offering renting only video which you can't buy. > What device that you own can’t play Spotify music? Anything they didn't think about? DRM-free formats can be accessed anywhere, you can re-encode them in any codec and etc. For example I can take my audio files and play them in RockBox on my portable Sansa player. How would Spotify help for that? Benefits of DRM-free are quite self explanatory.
- scarface74 8y agoI have 700 songs in my various Spotify playlists and growing. Back in the day I would have had to pay $700 for my songs. Now so pay $10 a month. I pay $10.99 for Netflix. That doesn’t pay for one movie, let alone a dvd box set.
- shmerl 8y agoI don't mind paying to creators for the music I'm listening to. Didn't you yourself say that it costs money to make?
- scarface74 8y agoThey are getting paid. I've never suggested pirating media. The streaming media companyed pay the creators. Netflix alone pays billions per year for Netflix.
- shmerl 8y agoSo do DRM-free stores like Bandcamp.
- scarface74 8y agoAll purchased digital music has been DRM free for a decade. Netflix says we watched about 60 hours last month and my son watched 5 seasons of "Everybody Hates Chris" on Hulu - combined price of both services was $23 a month. How much would that cost to buy?