3 ms·
But this is not how historians think about history. This risks presentism. History should be understood in its own context, not by the events that came afterwar
by UncleMeat 8y ago
But this is not how historians think about history. This risks presentism. History should be understood in its own context, not by the events that came afterwards. Presenting history backwards makes it feel like prior events happened in the context of future events when historical actors had no understanding of those future events.
Instead history is best understood in the context available to the people at the time.
- drb91 8y agoThe academic work of history and teaching history to non-historians have different constraints; the latter requires certain reduction to causality. Or at least that seems like the current state of affairs. I’m not necessarily a fan, but it’s better than no education at all.
- UncleMeat 8y agoDisagree totally. It is more important here. The reason we teach the humanities to non-experts is to teach empathy and the ability to fully separate from your own context. Teaching history backwards sabotages this effort.
- drb91 8y agoWhere and when and with whom would you propose teaching people? This is a solvable problem, but you have to justify being ABLE to just do it right the first time.