3 ms·
Exactly. You see the same thing happen in every other spot on the internet where users contribute content, and only an algorithm controls what dies, what lives,
by ryandrake 8y ago
Exactly. You see the same thing happen in every other spot on the internet where users contribute content, and only an algorithm controls what dies, what lives, and what gets rewarded. See also: the huge counterfeit goods problem on Amazon, review system gaming on Yelp, spam in almost any unmoderated online forum, etc.
This isn’t going to be solved with better algorithms or machine learning. The bad actors also have computing resources. I think it can only be solved by human curation.
- flyinghamster 8y agoIt's instructive to view Hacker News' own "new" page with "showdead" set. The torrent of spam is astounding. There seems to be absolutely nothing online that people aren't intent on ruining.
- iandanforth 8y agoI have to disagree, not because you're wrong, but because I am jaded. I think it will be solved by better algorithms and machine learning after it gets worse for a very long time. If there is a temporary replacement of algorithms with human curation the scale of the economic incentive to replace those workers is vast. An institution like Google or Amazon cannot look at a huge, low-skill workforce and not actively wonder how to replace them. I lived this personally as I was briefly an adwords editor. I was one of a huge cadre of BA's employed to enforce complex and messy rules about text ads. Simultaneously, embedded engineers watched us so they could better craft algorithmic replacements. Eventually they did. That experience was a non-zero factor in my transition into a technical career. Big companies will automate anything they can and being on the automation side rather than the automated seems like the better idea.
- ryandrake 8y agoAs automation gets better, do you think the bad actors are just going to shrug, say “well that was good while it lasted” and give up? Their automation will keep improving too. I’d argue that the spammers’ algorithms will always be better than their targets’ because their effort directly impacts their bottom line, whereas their targets’ anti spam efforts have to only catch enough to avoid turning their legit audience away.
- alasdair_ 8y agoThe same problems apply to email spam. It was bad for a long, long time but now it's a largely solved problem if you use (say) Gmail.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoIsn't that because most of the spam centers simply get blocked?