10 ms·
Dev Watercooler: World of Warcraft Classic
- vcfg 8y agoI like wotlk better, I think it was the best expansion, and I’m sure wotlk servers have more players than vanilla servers now. I don’t know why they chose vanilla over wotlk. :/
- makosdv 8y agoA vocal minority of the community was pushing for vanilla. There was a somewhat popular (supposedly 150k active players) vanilla server setup by some people in the community (Nostalrius) that was shut down by Blizzard for copyright infringement. It's hard to say what Blizzard will do after they roll out the vanilla servers. They may create TBC, WotLK, etc. servers, or it may be a dud that they just shut down... I'm sure it will depend on how successful they are and how much effort is required to maintain the servers.
- maccard 8y agoI wonder how many of those 150k will convert to paying players.
- nikanj 8y agoThe cost of running WoW servers per player must have plummeted in 15 years, thanks to both better devops and better hardware. They might be ok with a freemium model.
- falcolas 8y agoIf they haven't moved WoW proper to a freemium model, I highly doubt they'll do it for Classic. Look at EQ. The base game is freemium, but if you want to play on the latest progression servers, you need to pay their subscription price.
- falcolas 8y agoThere's also a vocal minority who are mad they're starting with 1.12; it has too many balancing changes for their taste. And another minority who wants the equivalent of EQ's progression servers - they don't want to be stuck at 1.12, they want all the same content releases again. And another minority who wants TBC. Another WotLK. Blizzard is going to be disappointing someone with every choice when it comes to classic. And a lot more people are going to be disappointed when they actually go and play that game. TBF, you couldn't pay me enough to go back and play a warlock with all the prep required to raid Molten Core (and all the "limited debuff slots" BS). That's a lie of course, I'd happily even mule a Paladin for your guild if you wish to pay me $300k+ a year.
- thewizardofaus 8y agoWotlk was like heroin for teenage me.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hugja 8y agoThis was my first thought too. Although I must admit I didn't play WoW until the release of BC (Burning Crusade) and stopped when Cata finished. So I never really got to experience what was special about Vanilla. More specifically for why I'd want WOTLK is for Arena. The last season was the most balanced that I ever experienced it and some of the most fun I've ever had playing WoW or any game in general. Jumping back to Vanilla one thing I hate about the current expansions is quest helper and honestly this rings true for other games (Destiny for example) as well. I think the lack of a quest/mission guide is a better experience for the player. I remember playing BC and had a blast trying to complete quest. You had to really pay attention and read the quest for specifics and clues to figure out what was needed or where to go. The completion of quest back then felt so rewarding. Now you just look at your map and follow the "little dotted line"[1] then rinse and repeat. This struggling with quest is what I'm most looking forward to with classic WoW. 1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FzOCkXsyIqo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FzOCkXsyIqo
- kbutler 8y agoBut it will be very, very hard to keep that experience. Where you used to have to turn to other players for help, building those social relationships as they struggled through the same challenges, now the web environment surrounding the game has evolved with very complete documentation an alt-tab away, and all the other players have that as well.
- masklinn 8y agoThat was already the case back when WoW was first released. Everquest (1) got pretty extensively documented during its lifetime (and mapped, there were no in-game maps until the 4th expansion).
- hugja 8y agoOh most definitely! It's certainly not for everyone. I mean even back then, if I'm remembering correctly. There was a site called Thottbot for exactly that. Which I occasionally turned to when the quest was lacking in information. Even before Blizzard officially added a quest helper to the game there was a third party add-on. However, with sites like Thottbot you still had to investigate to figure out what you had to do and I think this still gives you sense of accomplishment over just being told what and where all the time. Edit: words
- Vanit 8y agoI'm really interested to see where this leads. They got some quick wins out of this, but they're going to need to somehow revert a lot of game systems to get it back to something approximating the vanilla experience.
- highace 8y agoHere's my prediction: if you didn't play vanilla when it was available, you're gonna hate it. If you did play it, you'll go back for the nostalgia but will stop when you realise how tough the grind was. Those players will be late 20s and beyond now and won't have the time for it. It'll be interesting to see how many of those calling for this to happen actually stick around.
- booblik 8y agoSome of us are in the thirties already.
- zeth___ 8y agoI was in the beta in middle school. I'm in my 30s now. I won't be playing the game because it was about the people you met, not the places you went to. There is that screenshot floating around of the last player left in a guild under the screenshot of the full guild back in 2005: https://i.redditmedia.com/m4I50ji3u80G3FjSkFCcSpqb2ZHr-4Rcf08xnXtsuHw.jpg?s=ee97590207cf315a0bc5f64b2155cdeb https://i.redditmedia.com/m4I50ji3u80G3FjSkFCcSpqb2ZHr-4Rcf0... Just made myself realize that it will be the same time delta between the first and second picture and between the second picture and next year.
- TheAceOfHearts 8y agoThat really reminds me of the Overlord anime / light novels, where the main character ends up alone after having had tons of achievements with his guild. He's the only one still logged in when the game shuts down.
- sverrirs 8y agoBarrens. General. Chat... /shudder
- vcfg 8y agoThat will be a huge culture clash there. Current servers have a very anti-SJW population. WoW classic really is a classic game. I expect to read lots of angry Kotaku articles, haha.
- toxicFork 8y agoHypothesis: Talking while playing - even in the original sense, at the playground, or at the street, but we're moving more and more to the digital avenues - are a big factor in how children and young people form ideas and opinions, to see what's "cool" and "lame". The schools are where they are polished and shaped, with a tiny bit from parents - if they even talk about these things with their children anymore. If in the future we see "anti-swj" be the norm we could say that "well, we saw it in barrens chat". Similar with 4Chan back in the day and probably still now. I wonder if there are experiments going on using the data from ancient game chat and IRC channels (and so on) to verify this, and to check whether we can predict what may happen next. One scary part is some people may consider this as yet another platform and opportunity to manipulate and control the minds of the future.
- berbec 8y ago1. Where's Manrick's wife??!!!11one1!!!?
- dnate 8y agoI was surprised to find a game as big as WoW to have a data strucutre which clearly violates some basic forms [1] of database formalization. Isn't database normalizaton something that any cs program teaches in the first few semesters? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Database_normalization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Database_normalization
- mkreis 8y agoThere are very good reasons to violate it. Like performance - you would need to make a sub-select or join, which is costly. Also if you are 100% sure that "no one will ever need more spell effects", it is a valid way to go.
- jeremyjh 8y agoYou can't always run a normalized database though; often you need to denormalize for performance reasons. In very massive systems, a normalized database is rare.
- ckaygusu 8y agoI'm yet to have the privilege to work on a database which I would call truly "massive", so I'm oblivious to how things work in such environment in reality. I've seen the question and the answer you've given repeats many times, but aren't there exists a plethora of tools like table partitioning, materialized views etc. to allow one to have the database in a normalized form and run it fast? Don't they work in practice?
- jeremyjh 8y agoTable partitioning does nothing to solve the performance problems of joins of very large datasets. Materialized views can help but they are not a panacea. You have to trigger the updates yourself, and because they are updated asynchronously, you will not have a consistent view of your data. E.g. you could write a row to the database and not see it updated in your view for minutes.
- masklinn 8y ago
- taneq 8y agoIt's interesting to see them relating the trouble they've had with the old game client when thousands of us play on private servers using old game clients (1.12 is common for much the same reasons discussed.)
- kemayo 8y agoI suspect that their standards are different. Someone who's willing to jump through the hoops to play classic WoW on a private server likely has a willingness to deal with glitches and troubleshooting issues with running a 12-14 year old game client. Whereas Blizzard wants to provide a smooth official experience, which they're going to give to their mass market audience. They can't get away with saying "yeah, it crashes a lot, and runs terribly on New Video Card X, deal with it", because it makes them look bad. (For that matter, I suspect things like saying "that crash bug was there in 2007 as well, so it's the authentic experience" wouldn't go over fantastically...)
- 4ndr3vv 8y agoMore importantly, Blizzard want to have the same security they have currently with Battle.net et al.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ch0wn 8y agoReading option one made me quite anxious. Having to backport a virtually infinite number of bugfixes and support for new hardware features from over 12 years of constant development sounds like a perfect way to burn out developers. I'm glad they went for the clearly more sustainable option of adopting the old data to their new client infrastructure.
- mattmanser 8y agoIt will mean people will find loads of things that won't be the same though. Take balance. I'd be willing to bet they've done loads of bug fixes on unintended consequences of spells. So the Frostbolt of the new system might actually do a different amount of damage and slow than the Frostbolt of 1.12, once the data's been transformed. So all the classes will probably be slightly different to how they were in 1.12 and combos that worked back then might no longer work now. Some classes might now be OP that weren't and vice-versa. Monsters that were weak might suddenly become strong, and monsters that were hard might suddenly become really easy. Not that I'm saying it's the wrong solution, I think it's realistically the best one available to them. But it will probably result in a different gameplay experience rather than, say, just updating the visuals. How different won't be clear till later.
- 4ndr3vv 8y agoDon't think so. From what the article says, the majority of game defining data will remain the same, albeit modified to fit the new schema. Frostbolt will still be the same power, etc. The changes are to the global game infrastructure and how it interprets these data, so there will be some stuff that used to work that likely won't work now (eg wall walking) and things that were possible (speed hacking, water walking) that won't be possible now.
- killaken2000 8y agoIs this too little too late? After j Allen brack scolded the fans over how preposterous the question of classic servers was. And Blizzard shut down the two major classic servers. It's possible that the well is poisoned and people won't want to play out of principle or that they just moved onto other games and the time to capitalize on this has passed.
- RafiqM 8y agoIt was preposterous and still is. It just happens to also be what a vocal minority want, so here we are. There will be a tiny cohort of players who will play this and genuinely enjoy it. The rest will be people who thought it was amazing (it was, in 2004) but have not realized that for 2018, vanilla is in so many ways a bad game.
- kojon99 8y agoWhat has happened that makes vanilla a bad game in 2018?
- killaken2000 8y agonothing. But some people who think their opinions are facts don't like it.
- feefie 8y agoThe one thing that I suspect will be missing is new players. One of the things I enjoyed the most was seeing in chat a player that didn't know how to get from Iron Forge to catch a boat to the other continent, and I'd have fun showing him how to get through the Wetlands to the port. The Wetlands was a higher level than we were at the time the quests wanted us to visit the other continent, so it was a dangerous journey and you'd usually become friends by the time it was over. Of course everyone knows how to get there now, so I don't know how they can recreate the fun of helping someone out that is inexperienced. The same goes with dungeon fights, etc., -- everyone will already know all the tricks I expect. I certainly miss the days of exploring a brand new world, the likes I had never seen in a video game before, and helping others (and being helped by others) along the way. Wonderful times! :-)
- Merem 8y agoComing from someone who played Vanilla WoW (and also WoW in general) for the first time last year on a popular private server: Everyone always expects you to know everything, so one has to mention it quite often, especially when it comes to dungeons where the party decides to go for route X to farm possible loot item Y and you have no idea what they are going to do/break. I still had a lot of fun getting my character to level 60 though (and raising some others). Open world PvP is particularly great.
- wingerlang 8y agoI never played WOW in its heyday, but literally most of my friends did. I've been considering checking WOW out without reading any guides - as I think 'optimal play' makes games boring. So there might at least one 'new' player.
- aphextron 8y agoIt makes me really sad that they are including Battlegrounds in WoW classic. There was a magical period from release date to the first Battlegrounds patch where people actually took part in large scale, world PVP. Guilds would get together and raid towns, and it was the most fun I’ve ever had in an MMO. If you wanted to do something, it took lots of planning and working together with people, not just clicking a queue button while you sit in Ironforge. I feel like the vast majority of people started joining post-BC and never experienced this, but it was amazing.
- twoodfin 8y agoI remember those days. It would have been a very different game if Blizzard had decided to incentivize that kind of world PvP instead of leaving it essentially pointless. So much weird and cool stuff was possible in vanilla. I remember someone kited a Servant of Razelikh into downtown Stormwind. It could only be killed by activating some object back in the Blasted Lands, so a crowd of dozens of guards and PC’s who didn’t know any better just whaled on it for half an hour. EDIT: Apparently this was not just for lolz as you could level up weapon skill on the thing. Neat!
- RafiqM 8y agoDo you also remember the massive imbalances in world PVP? The majority of servers were significantly skewed towards one faction (my own was 3:1) which meant world PVP was super fun primarily for the overpopulated faction. This is the entire reason battlegrounds were introduced - balanced world PVP was unviable on almost every server. It was one of the primary complaints about the game, and could even have resulted in the loss of the PVP orientated player entirely if it had not been addressed.
- gknoy 8y agoThe new "War Mode" mechanics sound neat. It's an opt-in experience you set in a capital city, and then when you go out in the world you are in a _balanced_ shard of only others who opted in as well.
- s_m_t 8y ago
- seattle_spring 8y agoI still don't understand why they didn't go with either Diablo or Diablo 2. Much easier to make compatible with modern settings, much easier for new and casual players to get into, much easier to maintain, and arguably more people hungry to play it online over legacy WoW players.
- charlesdm 8y agoAnd likely much less profitable as well
- wmil 8y ago> Much easier to make compatible with modern settings, much easier for new and casual players to get into, much easier to maintain, I'm not sure that's true. Implementing classic wow in the modern client sounds like a straightforward data migration that will have some hiccups. The Diablo 2 code is probably a visual studio 5 project built in direct x 5, they'd have to port all that to something modern. Their server code would need to support their current login system, and is probably not even going to build on a current is without changes. On top of that Diablo 2 players aren't expecting a monthly charge. I don't think the money is there.
- swebs 8y agoI think "THE BLIZZARD RANT" explains it all: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzT8UzO1zGQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzT8UzO1zGQ
- Rebelgecko 8y agoDiablo 1 and 2 are still playable online today, so those who really want to play them already are. D1 and D2 are also harder to monetize than WoW, where there's the expectation of paying a monthly subscription instead of making a one-time purchase
- bcgraham 8y agoThe secret sauce of Vanilla was the sense of place and sense of community. You don't need the old patch. You need persistent identities and travel time. Small populations, no server or faction transfers, and walking to dungeons is the vast majority of it. I also really miss Vanilla dungeon design, where I felt like I was exploring a dangerous place instead of having a very scripted, linear experience. I loved Blackrock Depths, Maraudon, and Blackfathom Deeps. I get why these aren't economical for developer hours, but they are a magical experience.
- kemayo 8y agoSome of the longer dungeons were hard to run, though. I played Vanilla, leveling several different characters to 60, and I'm pretty sure I only managed to run Maraudon start-to-finish once. (Doing just the inner Mauradon shortcut to kill Princess was more common, admittedly.) I do kind of miss those things, I admit. Instances where you could find keys that would persistently unlock shortcuts, so if you came back later you could bypass bits of it. (Or if you were a rogue.) That said... the time investment required was quite ridiculous, in hindsight. I don't miss things like sitting in Ironforge for an hour saying "3DPS 1H LFTank" every few minutes... and then spending another hour getting from Ironforge to somewhere like Dire Maul (okay, or being the two? three? people in the group who volunteered to sit around by the dungeon to use the meeting stone to summon that tank when they showed up). The LFG tool exists for a reason.
- taneq 8y ago> I'm pretty sure I only managed to run Maraudon start-to-finish once. The early dungeons had a massive range of levels, though. IIRC the mobs in outer Maraudon were low 40s (high 30s?) whereas Princess Theredras was lvl 50. You weren't really meant to clear the thing in one sweep.
- gknoy 8y agoIt didn't help that Maraudon was in Desolace, and the only place harder and more time consuming to get to (for Alliance, at least) was Feralas. It was something like a half hour journey to get there, counting boat travel, gryphons, and riding yourself, so you ended up often only playing with people who were already there, or already questing in the area.
- ralusek 8y agoDoes anybody else find it weird that even their new data structure for spells still has to include columns whose value is "Nothing." Why are these spells even in a tabular database at all? It seems like each spell could simply be in a JSON file, or at the very least this seems like a suitable place to use a key-value store or a document database.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 8y agoI know it sounds dumb, but I can't help but being confused by the domain of the website. I expected blizzard related stuff would be ay least on a subdomain
- brod 8y agohow is this more blizz related than wow related?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]