3 ms·
The problem here is that in Aristotelian logic, which deals strictly in statements that are true or false and nothing in between, non-existent evidence is not e
by jerf 8y ago
The problem here is that in Aristotelian logic, which deals strictly in statements that are true or false and nothing in between, non-existent evidence is not evidence of non-existence. But this cute phrase, over-quoted and generally badly misunderstood, is not true because of the way the obvious, naive reasoning would lead you to believe... it is true because Aristotelian binary logic doesn't deal in anything like "evidence" at all. Non-existent evidence is not evidence of non-existence, because under this logic there is straight-up no such thing as evidence. There is only proof.
However, while this form of logic is a great thing to teach children for their first (and likely only) one, and while your fancier logics probably ought to have some sort of Correspondence Principle for this style of logic, this rigid style of logic is not terribly useful in the real world, where statements of rigid, solid, 100%-confidence mathematical truth are in short supply. In any probabilistic logic, non-existent evidence is evidence of non-existence. It is not proof. But it is evidence. It is true the human mind may have a tendency to overweight the evidence, but that's fixed by math.
So, while there is a sense in which the oft-trotted out phrase is true, in logics useful in the real world, it is simply false.
After all... what other evidence of non-existence do you expect to gather? If you do not believe in the invisible, intangible unicorn that lives in your garage that Sagan liked to talk about, what other actual evidence for that belief do you have other than a complete lack of evidence it exists? There is no way for you to disprove it under Aristotelian logic. (And this style of logic doesn't have a great story for statements it can neither prove nor disprove, which is another reason why mathematics moved past it a long, long time ago.)
If string theory is wrong, what other evidence for that can we gather other than the predictions of string theory being false? Remember, we can build physics models based on, say, Loop Quantum Gravity that excludes strings and may seem to predict the universe correctly, but that does not logically prove that there are not also strings in the universe. We exclude strings or other broken models only by consistently failing to collect evidence they are true.
- sgt101 8y ago>>We exclude strings or other broken models only by consistently failing to collect evidence they are true Which is not a reason to consider them excluded. There is no reason to believe in the unicorn, or strings it there are powerful predictive alternate theories that explain the observed facts. But science creates contingent knowledge, not truth, that is all.
- jerf 8y ago"Remember, we can build physics models based on, say, Loop Quantum Gravity that excludes strings and may seem to predict the universe correctly, but that does not logically prove that there are not also strings in the universe." - from just the previous sentence. Incidentally, that post gored some oxes, apparently. Despite the firm mathematical foundation I stand on with great confidence for the entire post, it's sitting at -2. Seems a lot of people have a very emotional reaction to hearing "absence of evidence is not evidence of absence" is untrue.