4 ms·
It is likely that the lax Chinese attitudes towards patents is one of the contributing factors to their highly agile and efficient technology sector. It has be
by jandrese 8y ago
It is likely that the lax Chinese attitudes towards patents is one of the contributing factors to their highly agile and efficient technology sector.
It has been noted for some time that one of the barriers to entry for a new company in the US is their lack of defensive patents.
- cma 8y agoThe part of the industrial revolution that happened in the US was similar (maybe more trade-secrets related): > In the UK, he was called "Slater the Traitor"[2] because he brought British textile technology to America, modifying it for United States use. He memorized the designs of textile factory machinery as an apprentice to a pioneer in the British industry before migrating to the United States at the age of 21. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samuel_Slater https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samuel_Slater
- Symmetry 8y agoAnd it wasn't just patents. The US was notorious for not respecting UK copyrights for most of the 19th century. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Pirates_of_Penzance#Background https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Pirates_of_Penzance#Backgr...
- raverbashing 8y ago"defensive patents" Yes, makes it sound like patents are a legalized protection racket.
- hueving 8y agoRight, protecting an investment in R&D is a protection racket. There has to be some reasonable line between incentivizing investment and "everyone had a right to everyone else's ideas".
- raverbashing 8y agoAgreed for more involved research, but for software, patents are a scam.
- int_19h 8y agoit is often said that software is just math, and math is not patentable. But any mechanical contraption is ultimately just physics at work, and physics is just math as well. So, what's the difference?
- mehrdadn 8y agoThere is nothing about software that makes patenting it inherently any worse than patenting hardware. The problem is rampant misuse/abuse/poor implementation.
- picsao 8y agoAnd that reasonable line looks like a mouse face 140 years after introduction. Rent seeking knows no reason and boundaries.
- Maarten88 8y agoThe article argues otherwise and backs it up with a plausible story from history, with two other stories (Switzerland and China) added above in the comments. At least it seems plausible that the current way of "incentivizing investment" is not working, and we might even be better off completely without it.
- mickronome 8y agoIf it is necessary with defensive patents for a new company to enter the market with an obviously not - in a quite literal sense - copied product, then it probably is something comparable to a racket. If it is also the case that patent holders purposely withold the very trade secrets that is the bargaining chips that gets you a patent according to the spirit of the law, then if it isn't a racket, it's still immoral and needs to stop being allowed. So many patents these days are completely devoid of the secrets they are supposed to both protect, and publish. Little is thus gained for the public good, and much is lost. It strikes me as odd that patents has such a strong support in the US, as generally there seems to be the case that the government isn't wanted where it's not absolutely needed, and I find it hard to see how one could argue that patents are so integral to society that they should fall in that category according to the metrics that seems to be used for other commonly government controlled areas.
- BartBoch 8y agoForm a startup that offers legal protection against patent trolls for $1-2,000/mo and you will have a winner...
- yayana 8y agoThere are patent groups you can buy into (with costs being less if you have helpful patents to share) and then use a shared patent portfolio to defend yourself. It isn't a startup because it needs a lot of resources and the patent portfolio isn't very useful against patent trolls because they intentionally have no production that could be infringing on anything. But I think they also act as insurance for defense costs.
- BartBoch 8y agoPatent groups are not the same as Patent Troll insurance imo. Latter would be much better (even if you would need to give up all patent right).