4 ms·
You appear to be downplaying the article. You write "just because someone has not committed a crime does not mean they cannot be taken to the hospital involunt
by eesmith 8y ago
You appear to be downplaying the article.
You write "just because someone has not committed a crime does not mean they cannot be taken to the hospital involuntarily". The article certainly doesn't disagree with that statement. It states: "Hennepin Healthcare staff are authorized to use ketamine when a patient is “profoundly agitated,” unable to be restrained and a danger to themselves or others, according to their policy."
Instead it is pointing out times where there does not appear to be a justifiable reason, and for situations where there seemingly should be a cut and dry decision. The morality point you brought up, while true, does not appear relevant to the topic at hand.
As an example of downplaying, the article talks about being handcuffed and secured to the stretcher. You turned that into two distinct cases, and gave an example of where each one separately has come up in your work. But how often have ended up in danger from people who were both handcuffed and secured to the stretcher?
The other use of "handcuffed" was from someone maced while intoxicated, who suffered an asthma attack as a result. The woman, who "was not actively resisting police, asked for an asthma pump. Instead they handcuffed her to a stretcher and gave her ketamine, the report said. ... It is also important to note that it appears no crime was committed, no threat to the safety of officer or paramedics was evident, ...".
Again, your abstract question of the morality of taking someone to the hospital involuntarily under any circumstance does not seem to be relevant.
You write "In many cases is it safer for the patient to use chemical rather than physical restraints." Certainly. Again, I don't think anyone disagrees. However, the article points out examples where both chemical and physical restraints were used. For example, a man secured to a chair, then "[w]hen the man began to regain consciousness .. [t]hey injected him with another dose of ketamine", causing him to stop breathing.
I interpret your true but abstract observations as a way to blur the concrete examples of problems highlighted in this piece.
- JshWright 8y agoI am not downlaying the article at all. I made it quite clear I believed it was likely the procedure was being abused. The anecdote of the asthmatic woman is particularly concerning. > But how often have ended up in danger from people who were both handcuffed and secured to the stretcher? Multiple times (I don't have a specific number). A stretcher is not intended to be used as an anchor for restraints. It's very difficult to keep someone restrained to a stretcher if they are continuing to fight. There is also a significant risk they will injure themselves. Finally, in some cases it is necessary to sedate a patient to provide treatment. The point of my comment is that it would be very easy for the article to omit details to make situations seem far less appropriate than they actually may have been (or that the abuse was more widespread than it actually was). EDIT: As your comment is starting to gray out, I think it's important to say that while I disagree with you, I think your comment is thoughtful and contributes meaningfully to the conversation (and certainly shouldn't be downvoted)
- eesmith 8y agoThank you for your support. I tried to highlight the specific reasons why it felt like downplaying. Another way to phrase my view would be, if someone did want to downplay the report, how would it come across? An outright rejection doesn't work. It's too easily dismissed. For example - and I make this comparison only to provide a well-known example - if you look at the anti-vaxxers, they don't outright reject vaccination. Instead, they argue that it should be examined more closely, there are uncertainties, and it's best to be cautious. No one can argue with those general statements. It's when you come down to specific things like "should all 6 month old babies (excepting medical reasons) be vaccinated for X" where the opposition comes into play. The opposition strategy is to take it back to the more abstract level, or bring up specific examples where vaccination might have caused a problem. I felt like your comment followed a similar pattern of switching to abstract principles that no one disagrees with. Someone who wanted to downplay the report would do that, to establish credential as being a reasonable person, and then use that credential to argue that things are more grey and nuanced than it appears. A third way to phrase my view would be as a complaint about switching to abstractions, which seems to minimize the concrete abuses of the actual people described.
- JshWright 8y agoI think where my comment differs from an anti-vaxxer's position is that I am an (admittedly self-described) content area expert. I am not attempting to discredit established science, I am providing more context that a layperson reading this article would otherwise lack. My concern with the article is that uses the same sort of vague and general statements that you're concerned with to argue against the use of sedation. For instance: "The police encounters that led to EMS using ketamine ranged from cases of obstruction of justice to jaywalking, according to the report. One man was dosed with ketamine while strapped to a stretcher and wearing a spit hood." To someone without the context of what these sorts of scenarios often look like, that sounds awful. As someone with a decade+ of EMS experience, I can think of a dozen calls that could be simplified into that paragraph. In every one of those cases in my personal experience I feel I acted in the best interest of the patient, while protecting my own safety and the safety of my crew. These are not decisions that are undertaken lightly, and even in cases where I'm 100% sure I made the right call, these are still the decisions I dwell on for the next couple days. You are absolutely right that my point is to argue that things are more grey and nuanced. Because they _are_. When I read this article, I think about all the time I've sedated someone, and the ways in which those scenarios could be simplified and twisted into a case where I "obviously" did the wrong thing. I'm not sure how you expect me to discuss this without using abstractions. I don't have specific knowledge of the cases involved, and it would be inappropriate for me to share all but the broadest details of the situations where I have personal experience.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI felt like he was trying to say "Let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater." It is really common for people to say "X is being abused. Proposed solution: Do away with X altogether." In this case, EMS sedation in certain situations where safety of the patient and/or others is at stake.
- eesmith 8y agoI don't see anyone proposing that solution, so just how common is it?
- DoreenMichele 8y agoIt's possible you aren't seeing it in this discussion because of the comment we are discussing. HN is less histrionic than most forums, but it isn't really as calm, cool and collected as it likes to imagine. Or, perhaps a little more charitably, the degree to which it manages to remain a sane discussion space hinges in part on the willingness of actual subject matter experts to inject such comments and then put up with being raked over the coals for it as if they are "apologists" for whatever nefarious behavior is under discussion.
- dang 8y ago"Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- eesmith 8y agoI believe I did that. Regarding that guideline, are commenters supposed to follow a similar guideline in how to interpret the source material, or are they free to make a weaker interpretation that is easier to criticize? Because one of my objections was how the article said that sedation was used on someone both handcuffed and strapped down, while the OP gave examples where someone handcuffed was sedated, and someone strapped down was sedated, but not both. That seems criticizing a weaker topic than what the article described. Similarly the article presented a case where someone was both physically restrained and chemically sedated, while the OP described chemical sedation as an alternative to physical restraint. That too feels like criticizing a weaker topic than what the article described. JshWright, to whom I replied, in another branch of this thread kindly commented "I think your comment is thoughtful and contributes meaningfully to the conversation."
- JshWright 8y ago> while the OP gave examples where someone handcuffed was sedated, and someone strapped down was sedated, but not both Ah, I think that's a case where my existing context led to a lack of clarity... If someone is "strapped" to the stretcher (i.e. not just the usual seatbelts), then their wrists are restrained (either in handcuffs, or using "soft restraints" to the side rails of the stretcher). The reality is, a stretcher is not designed to serve as an anchor for restraints, and someone who continues to fight over the course of a 20-30 minute transport will eventually work themselves free (at least enough to start kicking). Similarly, chemical restraint is always preceded by physical restraint. It's only when physical restraint isn't working (i.e. someone is fighting hard enough that there's a risk of injury) that chemical restraint is employed. It's in those cases that chemical restraint is safer (obviously continuing to wrestle with someone is more dangerous for everyone involved).