3 ms·
I always wonder, why unionised workers won't pursue investment in technology that will make their jobs obsolete rather than fighting a futile war against the te
by mrtksn 8y ago
I always wonder, why unionised workers won't pursue investment in technology that will make their jobs obsolete rather than fighting a futile war against the technology?
If you're an organisation of hundreds of thousands of workers, you probably can afford to invest in startups that can replace the jobs of the people you're representing. What's better, you already have a relationship with the client and your members have the know-how of the tasks and the business that's about to get automated.
If the investments fail, you keep your jobs. If your investments succeed, you no longer need to work to make living.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoWith shipping - there will be always be tons of manual work to do. It will just change in nature.
- mrtksn 8y agoYes but wouldn't be great for the workers if they had a stake in the company that makes the conveyor belt for example? We all have seen the graphs showing that the efficiency in the businesses increased dramatically while the salaries stagnated. Maybe they should pursue investment unions that are aiming to replace their jobs with technology so that they can take the rewards of the increased efficiency.
- gboudrias 8y agoIn a way, you're suggesting a cynical though (arguably) realistic stance. Which is logical, but a hard sell in the very political world of unions. A lot of these people have an emotional attachment to their job, or at least the idea of having a job. Edit: In other words, you can't put a price on purpose.
- ddebernardy 8y agoA lot of those automations require capital, which only the business in question will be able to provide at a reasonable cost.
- mrtksn 8y ago260K workers can provide the capital by investing a fraction of their salary. A 4K a year on average per worker will provide 1 Billions $ a year to invest in technology to make UPS jobs obsolete. There's no rule that one person or company should own all the machines that put people out of work, maybe it can be better for everyone if the machines are owned by a large number of private owners. Basically decentralised communism or if you want it to sound nicer, shared automation economy through crowdfunding.
- jaxn 8y agoThe knowledge required to build machines that can do the job would require intellectual property or trade secrets that the company owns.
- mrtksn 8y agoSure, what’s the problem?
- ddebernardy 8y agoA lot of people don't have the income level necessary to afford being able to spend a few bucks here and there on some investment.
- gomox 8y agoThe idea is interesting but intuitively I don't think the math works out. I understand the hedge angle, but done at large scale this type of investment -labor automation companies- is unlikely to yield very good returns (say, 10% yearly or so) and is therefore incapable of providing enough income for a worker to retire on (based on a plausible investment amount available to a unionized worker).
- mrtksn 8y agoGood point, but the idea here is that if the workers invest in the inevitable future and turn automation into a passive income instead of total loss for them(as it will happen when their trade is robotised by someone else). They might as well invest in anything else however collectively investing in the business they understand and are part of could bring considerable advantages such as educated “bets” in the startups and structured job losses(as not everyone will lose their jobs to the automation at the same rate) and all the the benefits that come with scale as opposed to individual micro investments.