3 ms·
“Why should the laws of nature care about what I find beautiful?” My suspicion is this is something we will forever wrestle with because "beauty" is a proxy sh
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
“Why should the laws of nature care about what I find beautiful?”
My suspicion is this is something we will forever wrestle with because "beauty" is a proxy shorthand measurement for things of real value, but it is confounded by an enormous and oft abused potential to use this fact fraudulently. That which has real value is often appreciated for its beauty, but the street doesn't run both ways. Seeking to make something look good doesn't necessarily give it the more valuable underlying properties.
In GIS school, I learned that a good map will typically be described as beautiful, but a beautiful map isn't necessarily good. A good map is elegantly designed to effectively convey information. When the goal is achieved, high quality design also has inherent aesthetic appeal. But trying to just make a map pretty doesn't make it more useful. In fact, it often makes it less useful.
I think the same principle generalizes. I was born with serious respiratory problems. I always had really lousy fingernails. With getting healthier, my fingernails have grown stronger and prettier. This makes me suspect that manicures and painted nails are about trying to enhance a signal of baseline good health that is inherently valuable and attractive. But painting your nails doesn't actually improve your respiratory health. Fake glued on nails can give an appearance of health that isn't real.
- BadThink6655321 8y agoMaybe we should care about beauty because Nature cares about beauty the way she cares about symmetry. I’m just spitballing here, but maybe Emily Noether’s intellectual heir will find a link between the conservation of energy and Kolmogorov complexity (if this hasn’t already been shown).
- DoreenMichele 8y agoMaybe beauty is merely a word for "my brain has crunched vast amounts of data and concluded that something very, very fundamentally appealing is going on here and I shall call that by a word suggesting visual appeal because I assessed that appeal with my eyes."
- perl4ever 8y agoMaybe "beauty" is ultimately a name for symmetry, where symmetry is a name for invariance under some transformation. And there is always a new type of transformation to consider and therefore a new and perhaps more subtle form of beauty.