2 ms·
> In Australia university admissions are based pretty much solely on one number [1] that represents your high school results (unless you didn't go to high schoo
by tzs 8y ago
> In Australia university admissions are based pretty much solely on one number [1] that represents your high school results (unless you didn't go to high school in Australia), plus bonus points if you are disadvantaged
How does this work with universities that have different focuses?
From the information at [1] and at your Wikipedia link, my understanding is that the way this number works is as follows.
• There is a large list [2] of standard courses offered by high schools that can count toward your ATAR score. Each course is either 1 or 2 "units". These include courses in English, foreign languages, science, math, history, business, arts, and others.
• This list is divided into two sections. The second, smaller section is courses that are lighter academic rigor and less demanding. The courses in the first section are called Category A course, and those in the second section are Category B courses.
• Your ATAR is calculated from your best 2 units in English, and your best 8 units from the rest, which can include no more than 2 units of Category B courses.
Suppose you have three students, all with the same ATAR number.
Student #1's score came from English, Biology, Chemistry, Mathematics, and Physics.
Student #2's score came from English, Dance, Drama, Music 1, Music 2, and Visual Arts.
Student #3's score came from English, Ancient History, Latin, Greek, and Modern History.
Do the universities these students apply to just see the ATAR number, or do they also see which courses went into its calculation?
If they all applied to whatever Australian school best corresponds to MIT or Caltech, for example, would the school be able to see that student #1 is probably the one they want from these three? If they all applied to Australia's most Julliard-like school, would it be able to see that student #2 is the one they want?
[1] https://www.uac.edu.au/ https://www.uac.edu.au/
[2] https://www.uac.edu.au/future-applicants/atar/atar-courses https://www.uac.edu.au/future-applicants/atar/atar-courses
- doubleunplussed 8y agoSpecific university courses will have additional requirements, for example my science course required an ATAR of 95, but also required a minimum score in a maths unit, and required that you completed some number of science units (I don't exactly remember). So based on the requirements, you couldn't ace English and then enrol in a science degree, for example. In practice the minimum scores required in specific units are more easily achievable than the ATAR, so the ATAR ends up being the limiting factor most of the time. Here is an example: https://www.monash.edu/study/courses/find-a-course/2018/science-advanced-research-s3002?domestic=true#current-y12ib https://www.monash.edu/study/courses/find-a-course/2018/scie... You can see the scores required in individual units are all 30. 30 is the mean by definition, whereas an ATAR of 95 means you're in the 95th percentile, so obviously if you're in the 95th percentile it's pretty likely you were above the mean in the relevant units. > Do the universities these students apply to just see the ATAR number, or do they also see which courses went into its calculation? I've been told by an administrative person in my department that there is in fact no system in place to verify that the students have completed the prerequisite high school courses or their scores. This is surprising to me but there you go. My memory is unreliable so this might not be quite right but I think I heard from the head a department that they just get ATARs and whether the applicant is from a socioeconomically disadvantaged background. So if that's the case and is true for other universities, then the advertised subject requirements etc mostly have the effect of encouraging students to self-select. Presumably after the fact, the university could ask a failing student to provide their high school transcripts, but basically they're not enforcing it up-front automatically. But I also get the impression things are just not as competitive as in the US. Most people live in the major cities and just attend the best university that their score allows, out of the universities in their own city. They don't care enough about going to the best school to move cities for it. The differences between the top 8 universities are not great enough for it to be worth moving when there is likely one in your city already.