4 ms·
You'd have to make it mandatory leave. How do you accomplish that without violating the right to privacy? If a man keeps coming into work and his partner is pr
by chongli 8y ago
You'd have to make it mandatory leave.
How do you accomplish that without violating the right to privacy? If a man keeps coming into work and his partner is pregnant, nobody has to know.
- dmayle 8y agoA woman doesn't have that possibility, so enabling that also encourages discrimination.
- chongli 8y agoI'm aware of that. This is a case where one right is in conflict with another. There's no good answer. One group of people is going to lose and another is going to win. The disadvantage women have is that they can't hide a pregnancy forever. Men can go to extreme lengths to hide their relationships. Although rare, it is not unheard of for a man to have two families at the same time, each one hidden from the other, and maintain this state of affairs for years before getting caught (otherwise we'd never hear about it).
- llukas 8y agoSociety doesn't need to and doesn't have any duty make this kind of arrangement easier to maintain. Also multiple marriages are illegal in Western countries.
- newfoundglory 8y agoHaving a family without marrying is not illegal, though.
- chongli 8y agoThe point about multiple hidden families was an example of the lengths men can go to in order to hide their relationships, not an endorsement of the practice. The fact is, an employer has no right to know what, if any, relationships the employee has, let alone the pregnancy status of them. The fact that employers discriminate against pregnant employees is the problem we should be addressing directly.
- Broken_Hippo 8y agoBirth records are public records, and if they aren't together, many states will require the father to pay child support once they figure out who he is. Sure, no one would have to know, but they can find out. If the non-pregnant partner carries the health insurance, they will probably want the pregnancy covered and the baby once it is born. An intelligent non-pregnant partner would change his tax exemptions to mirror their new family size (except in a few cases). The tax forms might be a key: Require everyone to be honest about their underage children, whether or not they are dependents, and give the option to claim fewer dependents on their tax forms. Yet another option is to handle it much like FMLA. The employer doesn't get the right to know exactly what is going on and the doctor can use medical codes instead of plain English. My ex's psychiatrist did this when he needed time off for a major mental illness (he later went on disability for said illness). The employer doesn't have to know, but he'll need similar notice.
- to_bpr 8y agoThis is incredibly dystopian and would be massive government and corporate overreach. I would hope a reasonable person would never advocate for such intrusion.
- Broken_Hippo 8y agoMost of these are already in place and they already have your information about your family. Insurance providers, the IRS, and so on. Women already have absolutely no choice in people knowing they are expecting a child. For health reasons - both theirs and the baby's - they already need to take time off. It isn't like women can claim a back injury when they are pregnant. A few bad employers already put their hands in whether or not health insurance covers birth control. If this stuff is dystopian to you, you are already living in one. Birth records are already there. Most employers won't look unless law, and I agree this isn't the best way to do it. However, if some time off is mandatory, it'd be reasonable for the state to inform the father he's required to take time off after the baby. Following the law would be his responsibility: The employer would only be forced to comply if they knew. There are already regulations (either through law or company policies) about adding a child onto your health insurance. Most times, folks have to upgrade their health insurance to a family plan if it is their first child. For other children, they already have to report that to health insurance so the child is covered. A reminder from the insurance that the law requires parental leave as well as maternal leave would be prudent. These folks already are handling your information now. FMLA is already in place. These folks already handle health records, and as mentioned, the reason can stay hidden from employers to an extent.
- lovich 8y agoDon't think that you could, or that you'd want to. There's multiple groups here with conflicting interests and not everyone is going to get everything they want. Does a subset of men's desire to privacy trump both women's right to equality and the child's right to get care from its parents?