3 ms·
WOW. How about misleading people with cherrypicked examples? That is what is done in Multiple Testing and reporting “sensational” findings. Here are two links:
by EGreg 8y ago
WOW. How about misleading people with cherrypicked examples? That is what is done in Multiple Testing and reporting “sensational” findings. Here are two links:
https://www.marketwatch.com/story/10-most-expensive-neighborhoods-in-the-us-2012-11-06 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/10-most-expensive-neighbor...
https://xkcd.com/882/ https://xkcd.com/882/
Relevant topics:
Simpson’s paradox
Multiple testing
Confirmation bias
Tons of people on HN live in the bay area so they can’t imagine things being even more expensive elsewhere in the country. Thus a critique of the methodology behind the loaded headline is dismissed, even voted down.
- beat 8y agoWelcome to HN. Violate the GroupThink, get downvoted into oblivion. It's happened to me twice in two days (and for one of them, I knew when I posted that it would happen). But back to my point... the true generalization is that the Bay area, broadly, is the most expensive place in the US to live. Worse than New York. If you narrow down, you can find individual blocks of New York that are more expensive, but across the entire metro? Sure, the headline/argument is a little sensationalist. But reducto absurdum in the other direction is no better.