4 ms·
>There is no state, metropolitan area or county in the U.S. where workers earning minimum wage can afford a two-bedroom rental home by working 40 hours a week,
by dsfyu404ed 8y ago
>There is no state, metropolitan area or county in the U.S. where workers earning minimum wage can afford a two-bedroom rental home by working 40 hours a week, according to the study.
This seems like an unreasonably high standard for a single minimum wage income unless they're using the excess here as a proxy for other necessities.
Edit: This seems unreasonably high because it greatly exceeds the standard of living we expect for a single minimum wage income household. Sure it would be nice if a single minimum wage household could rend a 2br but that's not what we currently expect them to be able to do. Saying "people who make X can't afford Y" when we didn't expect them to afford Y in the first place isn't very meaningful when you're discussing the ability of people making X to have a standard of living that meets our expectations for people making X.
- chrisseaton 8y agoTo need two bedrooms on a single income I guess you have a child or someone else you are supporting like an elderly relative, and possibly a partner as well. So that means attempting to support a family of two or three on one minimum-wage job.
- monocasa 8y agoWhich was the status of minimum wage jobs up until the mid 1970s. The average minimum age worker is 35, so it's not really fair to say "just don't have kids". https://mobile.nytimes.com/2014/06/10/upshot/minimum-wage.html https://mobile.nytimes.com/2014/06/10/upshot/minimum-wage.ht...
- ggg9990 8y agoYeah... why would you be able to rent a 2BR house on minimum wage. More like a shared room in a house.
- antisthenes 8y agoExactly, and I'm not sure where people's entitlement here comes from. American 2-BR apartments in upscale complexes are HUGE (I've seen figures as high as 1300 sq. ft), and in Europe they would easily have a 3-4 person family living in them, with more than 1 person working.
- frgtpsswrdlame 8y agoWhy does that seem unreasonable to you? Seems to me that there should be tons of places in this country where anyone would be able to afford to rent a small house. That literally none exist is pretty damning.
- TheLoneAdmin 8y agoI cannot remember a time when one minimum wage job was enough to rent a two-bedroom. I rented my first apartment, with roommates, in the 80's.
- monocasa 8y agoMinimum wage as adjusted in comparison to rent and home values, started going down in the mid 1970s, so that makes sense that you may not have seen it.
- cimmanom 8y agoThere was a time when one could. The minimum wage was originally put in place to make sure a single wage earner could support a family.
- PopsiclePete 8y agoA time when unions were strong, when the 1% were taxed at ~90% and when "social security" and "pensions" were not evil words. I feel zero sympathy for Americans and for the utter clusterfuck of misery that awaits them over the next 20 years. This is just the beginning.
- pofilat 8y agoThere never was a 90% tax rate. That was a marginal rate, and there were massive deductions.
- monocasa 8y agoThen name those massive deductions. Edit: or just drive by downvote, I guess.
- crooked-v 8y agoYou should expect people to downvote when you demand information you could get yourself just by skimming Wikipedia articles.
- monocasa 8y agoI asked about deductions, not just the marginal rate. That's not covered in the wikipedia articles.
- pofilat 8y agoFrom the 1950s, when the marginal rate was >90%: https://taxfoundation.org/taxes-rich-1950-not-high/ https://taxfoundation.org/taxes-rich-1950-not-high/ > per the Piketty, Saez, and Zucman data ... The average tax rate on the 0.1 percent highest-income Americans was 50.6 percent in the 1950s, compared to 39.8 percent today. From 1979 onward: http://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/cbofiles/attachments/effective_tax_rates2004.pdf http://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/cbofiles/attachments/... Highest effective tax rate, before Reagan's reforms, was 37% of the income of the top 1%
- TheLoneAdmin 8y agoThe price of the rental is derived: ========== Fair Market Rent (FMR) is typically the 40th percentile of gross rents for standard rental units. ========== A. If you are at minimum wage, look for apartments in the 5th percentile, not a mid-range priced apartment. B. Most minimum wage, one-income households only need one-bedroom apartment. C. Or, get a roommate, rent drops in half.
- kingbirdy 8y agoThe minimum was wage enacted such that a single breadwinner earning minimum wage would be able to support a family. A family needs 2 bedrooms and a livable apartment, not the bottom of the barrel, squeezed in to one bedroom.
- pofilat 8y agoDo you have a source? The numbers don't back you up. Min wage is the single-person poverty level, and is much higher now than when it was enacted.
- _dps 8y agoAt least in the US this is not true. The very first minimum wage, inflation adjusted, comes out to something like $8k/yr in today's money (https://bebusinessed.com/history/history-of-minimum-wage/ https://bebusinessed.com/history/history-of-minimum-wage/). It is simply not viable or desirable to require the lowest skill jobs to pay enough to support a family. It has never been the case that the least skilled laborers in an economy were able to support families without support from other sources (e.g. a multigenerational house).
- ahoy 8y ago> This seems like an unreasonably high standard for a single minimum wage income Why should it be though?
- pofilat 8y agoBecause not all jobs are that valuable. This is essentially replacing welfare by minimum wage, and why should welfare be administered non-progressively through employers instead of the government tax and redistribution? Should it be illegal do do low positive value work?
- gascan 8y agoBecause not all jobs are that valuable. No argument. But you seem to be making a value inference that low-value jobs aren't good enough to merit the worker a 2br place without two incomes. Why not? What level-sets what you "should" be able to get, for your low-value work?
- pofilat 8y agoThe market sets the value, obviously. Social welfare is great -- Medicaid, Unemployment, SNAP, WIC, etc, but shouldn't be paid directly by employers to recipients. Why should an unemployed person getting a low-value job suddenly shift all their welfare support burden from the state to their employer?
- TheLoneAdmin 8y agoConversely, you are arguing that a minimum wage worker should be able to rent a mid-range (40%) 2-bedroom apartment. Who is suppose to rent the cheaper 10-20% apartments? Why do you think the lowest 4% in wages of USA population deserve an average apartment? Minimum skilled worker = minimum wage salary = minimum quality apartment.
- gascan 8y agoThat's a good consideration, but you're forgetting about the part-timers & the unemployed. I'm not arguing that minimum wage should merit a 2br. I'm just challenging the notion that it shouldn't. There seems to be a sort of, "if you don't work hard and make lots of money, you don't deserve good things", built into that notion. When really, there's not exactly an intrinsic reason why a 2br is too good for a minimum wage worker. If it's a tight city with high demand and not enough housing, sure, competition for scarce 2br is intense. But if there is plenty of space & housing, why not? SF is a microcosm, most of the country is not like that.
- glup 8y agoI would like to see the comparison for the EU or Japan... I found this https://www.citylab.com/equity/2015/06/where-europeans-spend-the-most-on-rent-mapped/396833/ https://www.citylab.com/equity/2015/06/where-europeans-spend..., which suggests it is more reasonable, but doesn't reflect the minimum wage. Maybe it isn't such an unreasonably high standard?