3 ms·
> Has there been a misunderstanding of my comment? I didn't mean to say that I expect "AI to go away" The "it" in your original comment makes the subject ambig
by sangnoir 8y ago
> Has there been a misunderstanding of my comment? I didn't mean to say that I expect "AI to go away"
The "it" in your original comment makes the subject ambiguous - your comment can be interpreted as saying AI itself (not the arms-race) will "fizzle out".
I agree that AI's hype cycle is nearing the "trough of disillusionment" stage, but after that will come a wider and deeper application of AI in a multitude of fields and industries instead of the narrow applications today. Even the diminished returns are worth chasing if it increases your turnover by 1-2%.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> I agree that AI's hype cycle is nearing the "trough of disillusionment" stage, I'm sorry but I never said anything like that. AI is not the same as deep learning. It's deep learning that has been hyped in the last few years, not AI in general. Of course, in the lay press, there is a great confusion between AI, machine learning and deep learning- but I don't see why there should be an assumpion that I, too, am equally confused about those terms. In any case, it should be easy to dispel any misunderstandings by a quick look at my profile- I'm an AI PhD research student. I would hardly claim that AI is about to fizzle- or even deep learning. What is being discussed in the quote from the original article is the purported arms race to AGI. And how could AI "fizzle" now- when it has been growing as a field for the last 60+ years? Honestly, I don't see how any other interpretation of the "ambiguity" in my comment can be justified, assuming good faith. I sure had to squint really hard to see any ambiguity at all.
- evrydayhustling 8y agoIt sounds like we (in this thread) are all on the same page about the future of AI-writ-large. Regarding good faith, the quotation pattern you used didn't mention deep learning - you referred to either "the arms race" or "classifiers on large datasets" as fizzling out, and my reply resolved them to "AI" as a spanning term, since that was the context of the original post you quoted. For what it's worth, I would have written the same response about deep learning specifically for the same reasons you point out later in the thread that AI will remain useful. The specific profile of opportunities opened by DL is finding plenty of valuable homes in corporate processes where other kinds of automation fill in the gaps between it and AI. At this point, I'm not sure whether you disagree with that, or just think that some hype could afford to fade (no argument!). Since you are a grad researcher, I'll throw in some of my context. I did my PhD focused on probabilistic graphical models, back when it was easy to ignore NNs (and when we expected to hit some of the same perceptual milestones). As a grad student, a big part of your job is to filter fads and find ideas that will stay true. Because of that, I was slower than I could have been to recognize the feedback loops in what is "true" about applied AI. Deep learning's initial fit for some architectures and problems has attracted attention that made it much cheaper and easy to experiment, and therefore useful for more and more - even gobbling up adjacent techniques and giving them new names (over any manner of academic protest). That feedback loop isn't unbounded, but I guess I'm just sharing the perspective that hype, while annoying, isn't something that even a grad student can afford to disdain.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> At this point, I'm not sure whether you disagree with that, or just think that some hype could afford to fade (no argument!). I think I agree. I believe the hype is primarily driven by industry looking for applications rather than researchers looking for, er, well, understanding, hopefully. >> Because of that, I was slower than I could have been to recognize the feedback loops in what is "true" about applied AI. Deep learning's initial fit for some architectures and problems has attracted attention that made it much cheaper and easy to experiment, and therefore useful for more and more - even gobbling up adjacent techniques and giving them new names (over any manner of academic protest). That feedback loop isn't unbounded, but I guess I'm just sharing the perspective that hype, while annoying, isn't something that even a grad student can afford to disdain. You're right of course. Deep learning has earned its due respect I think and although I expect the field to look for something new eventually, I'm guessing that CNNs and LSTMs in particular will remain as established techniques, probably incorporated into other work. I mean, until some new technique comes up that can match CNNs' accuracy but with much improved sample efficiency and generalisation, CNNs are going to remain the go-to method for image classification. Like, I don't disdain deep learning, I did some work with LSTMs for my Master's and I'm thinking of using CNNs for some vision stuff after my PhD (my subject woulnd't really fit). It's just, there's so many people publishing on deep learning right now that I don't see the point of joining in myself.
- evrydayhustling 8y agoLooks like you are doing some cool stuff based on learning of structures! And indeed, the folks who are now celebrated for DNNs were doing the less popular thing for 10-20y prior :) Best of luck on your research.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoAh, I've been telling myself that, yes. Cheers :)