3 ms·
government controlled future What I find amazing is that anybody would utter that phrase and not consider it a "cruel joke" in and of itself. Government is ant
by mindcrime 8y ago
government controlled future
What I find amazing is that anybody would utter that phrase and not consider it a "cruel joke" in and of itself. Government is antithetical to Freedom and self-ownership, and there's no particular reason to aspire towards a future where everything (or most everything) is controlled by the government.
That is even more true when you realize the truth that "the government" and "the corporations and wealthy individuals" collapse into the same thing in the end.
There will (probably) always be battle between decentralized power and power that aggregates in the hands of entities like corporations and governments. Everyone should keep this in mind, and always remind themselves that both governments and corporations are a threat to Freedom, autonomy and self-ownership / self-direction.
- krapp 8y agoYou shouldn't be amazed that not everyone is, or historically has been, an anarchist who views government as antithetical to capital-F freedom (whatever that's supposed to mean.)
- mindcrime 8y agoWhile I personally am an anarchist, that isn't actually relevant to what I was saying above. There really isn't any actual question that government (as a centralization of power in the hands of a few) is antithetical to the freedom of individuals to live without fear of coercion. But in this context, I'm not arguing for a totally stateless society with NO government at all. In this context, I'm just saying that I find it amazing that people (apparently) want a "government run future" - a phrase which, to me, suggests a much higher level of government control of the details of our lives, compared even to what we have now. Now we may just be quibbling over the semantics of what "government run future" means, which is fine. It just jumps off the page at me as something that is far from being self-evidently desirable.
- krapp 8y agoBear in mind, we're talking about the future past, and probably a particularly American one. Before cyberpunk and dystopia in science fiction became more common, certain premises like the value of centralized authority, militarism, colonialist ideals and even eugenics were often taken for granted (depending on the author.)
- nickthemagicman 8y ago>Government is anti-thetical to self ownership. Government being the only reason ownership is possible without constantly fighting off invaders. Thank you laws.
- 0x445442 8y ago> Government being the only reason ownership is possible Assertion not necessarily fact. There are other models one can imagine which would refute this claim.
- nickthemagicman 8y agoWould love to hear of an alternative way to enforce ownership given human beings incredibly bloody 10k years of history.
- mindcrime 8y agoThat is a fair point, but it's leading us down the rabbit hole of debating exactly what we mean by "government". I say groups of individuals can choose to voluntarily band together to exercise what Bastiat described as "the collective extension to our individual innate right to self defense". You might say "but that is government". I on the other hand would say that the word "government" implies something more, based on how present day implementations of the term "government" function. The main distinction I would make is that, in practice, "governments" tend to arrogate to themselves the "authority" to do things that no individual could do themselves. And in my world-view, if an individual can't rightfully do something, then neither can a group of individuals, no matter how large. All of this is ultimately just me paraphrasing Bastiat, so for anyone who isn't already familiar with his works, and who finds anything interesting in this line of thinking, I suggest reading The Law[1]. [1]: http://bastiat.org/en/the_law.html http://bastiat.org/en/the_law.html
- nickthemagicman 8y ago>And in my world-view, if an individual can't rightfully do something, then neither can a group of individuals, no matter how largebased organization. This is interesting idea. Do you have any examples of this incorrectly applied in modern times? At it's core the law takes away the permission to apply violence from your average person and puts it in the hands of supposedly fair/blind judges. From Bastiat: "It is the substitution of a common force for individual forces. And this common force is to do only what the individual forces have a natural and lawful right to do: to protect persons, liberties, and properties; to maintain the right of each, and to cause justice to reign over us all." So ultimately were making the same point I think about protection of property? You feel like the govt has crossed a boundary somewhere though and I'm curious where.
- madeuptempacct 8y agoViews like yours become a lot more interesting if someone managers to reconcile them against monopolies and lack of free education, public works, etc in the absence of government. I.e. what's your alternative?
- 0x445442 8y agoLet's start with a Government considerably smaller in scope. I'd be willing to accept protections against monopolies, "free" education in the form of vouchers, public works if we got rid of most everything else.