4 ms·
I suspect Google App Maker will end up effectively abandoned like Google Web Designer: https://www.google.com/webdesigner/ https://www.google.com/webdesigner/
by pavlov 8y ago
I suspect Google App Maker will end up effectively abandoned like Google Web Designer:
https://www.google.com/webdesigner/ https://www.google.com/webdesigner/
Google dabbles in these tools, but the business case isn't really there. If anything Web Designer should have been more likely to succeed because it had a direct application — designing rich ads — that would benefit Google's primary moneymaker.
- ratsimihah 8y agoTo add some subjective constructive feedback, I think the idea behind App maker is crap.
- esrauch 8y agoCan you explain why the idea is crap? Broadly it seems bad if it takes a software developer to make even the most trivial app.
- konradb 8y agoI'm also interested in why you think it is a crap idea as opposed to complaints about the implementation or UI.
- ratsimihah 8y agoI don't think a layer of abstraction that hides away the complexities of building apps is a solution to a problem to begin with. I'm probably wrong and biased by the fact that not only does it take away the fun in engineering products, but also that the target demography is "business."
- SirYandi 8y agoPerhaps not a solution to complex applications, but for trivial apps what's wrong with hiding a little complexity? Say, by reducing the complexity of a tool that encourages a programmatic mindset you make it easier for new learners to get started who otherwise may have been scared away. I'm not quite sure why you have a bias towards business targeted platforms... most things are these days I suppose!
- strig 8y agoHow is that constructive in any way?
- ratsimihah 8y agoThat was sarcasm, I'm sorry.
- havetocharge 8y agoYou may need to brush up on what 'constructive feedback' means.
- segmondy 8y agoIt's a tool for businesses to get a web site presence so they can pay Google money to promote their sites. If it makes money, they will keep it. Think about it, Google is paying $300-$400k per engineer, if they have 10 people working on this that's $3-$4 mil per year plus the cost of infrastructure. If the experiment doesn't pan out after a few years, they will kill it. It's strange to me that HN is a crowd that embraces the idea of "experiment often and toss it if it doesn't work" but then is shocked when Google does the same.
- pavlov 8y agoWe’re basically in agreement, right? Getting App Maker to the point where its bottom line contribution can be shown to exceed $4M/a by 2020 seems like tall hill to climb.
- occams_chainsaw 8y agoIf they want to experiment with something, keep it in Google Labs Oh wait...
- enraged_camel 8y ago>>If it makes money, they will keep it. In large organizations, things are never that simple. There are about a hundred other factors that go into deciding whether a project or initiative is maintained or abandoned. Lawsuits, corporate politics, changing company direction, acquisitions and sell-offs... things rarely come down to "we're making a profit on this so let's keep it alive." Then there's also opportunity cost. Let's say the project has a 200% profit margin: total revenue is two times total cost. That still doesn't mean it won't be abandoned, because someone might decide that those resources can be better spent on another project that has a 300% profit margin. Basically what I'm saying is, don't count on App Maker to be a long-term project. There is literally no way to know, but lots of reasons to suspect it will be abandoned (based on Google's track record alone).
- 2_listerine_pls 8y ago> It's a tool for businesses to get a web site presence so they can pay Google money to promote their sites. It's designed to make internal tools, read the freaking description.
- petra 8y agoThe business is simple: helping companies get stuck on Google's cloud, Same as microsoft sharepoint/power-apps(?) and Amazon is also working on such tool.
- blisterpeanuts 8y agoApp Maker requires G Suite, which is a paid subscription service ($10/user/month for the "best deal" business tier). Probably they're hoping to grow their G Suite subscription base by offering some more value added services like App Maker. It's not a bad idea. Build your apps quickly and simply using App Maker, and you are then dependent on G Suite. However I do agree that Google has a disappointing track record when it comes to end-of-life-ing interesting products like Web Designer. It's hard to make a business case these days that we should adopt a particular tool that magically builds web sites or marries Java to web, or other such experiments, when it might be orphaned 2-3 years from now. Even if the Goog keeps it on life support, you don't want to be using a platform that has been abandoned by a critical mass of devs -- fewer resources out there to support it, answer questions etc. We'll take a wait-and-see stance on this one.
- jonnydubowsky 8y agoGood point. Does that change the economics model to one closer to Netflix, where the goal of the development costs is to hook more people into the subscription?
- shostack 8y agoThe lock-in is a concern. At least Google Sheets can be migrated to Excel somewhat easily. What's the migration path look like for App Maker if you want to leave G Suite?