10 ms·
SpinLaunch raises $40M to build a machine to catapult objects into space
- trhway 8y agoKind obvious solution when you loop the idea of long gun launch into a fast spinning ferris wheel. Much easy and simpler power delivery. Centripetal acceleration bites though.
- piker 8y agoWill reaching max q at sea level limit how much energy they can put into the projectile?
- Maybestring 8y agoDrag being a factor of velocity squared means diminishing returns for increasing launch velocity, but there's no hard limit.
- JumpCrisscross 8y agoThe tyranny of Tsiolkovsky's rocket equation [1] results from the need to burn fuel now to accelerate fuel for later. "Catapulting" sidesteps this issue by energizing on the ground. In selling away the rocket equation you buy yourself drag. Lots of energy up front means lots of drag. Overcoming that drag means more energy and, hence, more drag. The middle child of this solution is tremendous G force. You can't slingshot complex things into space. Pretty much just fuel and raw materials. That means you need in-space (a) refueling and (b) additive manufacturing capabilities. There are teams working on both problems, though they are presently in the domain of science versus engineering. Perhaps that will now be incentivized to change. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsiolkovsky_rocket_equation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsiolkovsky_rocket_equation
- tomp 8y agoHow much do you "gain" by launching from up hight (e.g. the Andes / Himalayas, as opposed to sea-level like in Florida)?
- changelink 8y agoIt saves you about 6% of fuel, assuming the launch location is on the equator, is suitable for roads and can handle a lot of noise / avelanches. Getting into space is the easy bit (energy-wise). Getting up to orbital speed takes much more fuel and energy. The problem is that now you have to transport everything near and up the mountain, which costs a ton in logistics (getting a road up a mountain that can handle a entire assembled rocket isn't cheap, nor easy). Most launches have delta-v to spare because satellites are usually nowhere near the rocket's maximum payload weight. tl;dr it can save 6% in a ideal situation, but the extra cost and logistical problems aren't worth it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mkstowegnv 8y ago>tl;dr it can save 6% in a ideal situation, but the extra cost and logistical problems aren't worth it. Unless you launch by means of a mass driver/rail gun [1] built into the side of Mt Everest with a piggy backed elevator for tourists. Tourists would arrive to a pressurized viewing area at the summit and have the option of donning an oxygen mask, going outside and posing for photos next to a cutout of Sir Hillary. I have never understood why serious rock climbing friends get so upset whenever I have mentioned this idea over the years. 1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_driver https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_driver
- gnode 8y ago
- arkh 8y ago> In selling away the rocket equation you buy yourself drag. Lots of energy up front means lots of drag. Overcoming that drag means more energy and, hence, more drag. The middle child of this solution is tremendous G force. Would it be possible and useful to do it with a 2 payloads system: one dumb piece of material first which can take lot of G followed closely by your "fragile" payload using its draft?
- jbattle 8y agoYou have to accelerate both pieces to the same speed, which implies (in a rotational launcher), the same G (acceleration). Maybe there's some configuration where the leading payload pushes air out of the way for the first few km (the 'real' payload drafting behind), but the blocking payload isn't given enough energy to reach orbit and falls short. Seems like the following payload would crash into the leading one though.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> followed closely by your "fragile" payload using its draft? G-forces [1] are a consequence of acceleration. An accelerating object will experience g-forces in an atmosphere or in a vacuum. ("Drafting" [2] is an aerodynamic process by which a following object exploits a leading object's slipstream to reduce the former's drag.) With a slingshot, the destructive force is the g-force inflicted by the acceleration. (With a rocket, the destructive forces are mostly vibrations and aerodynamic stress.) Note that a slingshot doesn't require lots of Gs. One could use a super-long slingshot to achieve the necessary velocity. But super long is super expensive, so high Gs it is. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G-force https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G-force [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drafting_(aerodynamics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drafting_(aerodynamics)
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoI can imagine a heavy dead weight accelerated in the slingshot. Once released, it drags a cable, carefully laid out at an angle, with the payload attached. That payload would be accelerated into line behind the weight over a brief period. Taking fewer Gs and only once. Very long cables are a lot cheaper than very large slingshots? Anyway just thinking out loud.
- kuprel 8y agoIs it possible they spin the rocket in place then convert the rotation energy to linear with fins on the body acting as a propeller?
- kuprel 8y agoSo just a quick calculation: Assuming that the rocket has moment of inertia similar to a hollow cylinder with radius 1ft, conversion from rotation energy to linear is perfect, and final linear velocity is 5000 mph, the rocket would have to be spinning at 1/2 * I * w^2 = 1/2 * m * v^2 1/2 * (m * r^2) * w^2 = 1/2 * m * v^2 w = v / r = 7333 rad/s ~ 70,000 rpm Maybe the payload of the rocket could be connected to the body of the rocket with magnetic bearings so that it isn't spinning, i.e. not experiencing the massive accelerations.
- bufferoverflow 8y agoAssuming you can 1) accelerate fast enough to penetrate the atmosphere at high speeds (and remember, the faster you travel, the air resistance is the square of your velocity). 2) withstand the crazy max-q as soon as you leave the spiral (which I assume is vacuumed). 3) make the centrifugal forces reasonable during the acceleration The article mentions acceleration to 5000mph, which would be enough if there was no atmosphere, but I highly doubt it will work with.
- dforrestwilson 8y agoHadn’t occurred to me before but this article made me curious. Every time that an object leaves our planet’s atmosphere we (apparently) minutely change the earth’s orbit. https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/26733/does-launching-a-device-into-orbit-change-earths-orbit https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/26733/does-launchi...
- astrodust 8y agoEvery time you fart you minutely change the Earth's orbit.
- ravar 8y agoNo actually. The mass doesn't leave the earth.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoThe mass leaving the surface and entering orbit around Earth doesn't change the location of the pair's center of mass.
- astrodust 8y agoIf it affects rotation, which it will to an immeasurable degree, it'll affect the orbit, though I doubt by less than an amount we could ever measure or simulate.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- beaconstudios 8y agoI wonder what the flight path would have to look like - I assume you wouldn't be able to accelerate in a circle on the ground and then tilt upwards because of the G force of the tilt. So you would either sling horizontally at a fairly slight incline (taking advantage of the curvature of the earth, but imagine keeping that flight path clear), have a slowly increasing ramp that would probably have to be really long to manage the G force, or accelerate in a vertically-oriented loop (which would have to be huge to cope with faster speeds). I'm guessing the slow ramp is most practical. Either way, there's some interesting info on the concept at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_gun https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_gun and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_driver https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_driver.
- tlrobinson 8y agoIf the radius of the ramp is the same as the loop wouldn’t it experience the same acceleration once diverted to the ramp? (but in a different direction)
- beaconstudios 8y agoI did the maths and if I'm right (I'm terrible at maths) then a loop would be impractical for any reasonable G force anyway - the radius would have to be over 100km for even 50gs. I'm guessing they'd need some kind of linear acceleration, in which case they can just point upwards anyway.
- zer0faith 8y agoCan someone ELI5 how this Space Catapult should "theoretical" work?
- gnode 8y agoThe article is very light on details, but I believe what's being proposed is an evacuated tube with maglev propulsion, used to accelerate a rocket up to 5000mph (as stated in the article) while on the ground. The rocket is then released, and travels until some altitude is reached, at which point engine then starts and it continues to orbit. This results in a large fuel saving over a conventional rocket. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_driver https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_driver The g-forces involved would be very high, well beyond lethal to a human, so this would be for launching robust satellites, raw materials, or fuel cheaply into space. They would still be substantially lower than those of a space gun / intercontinental artillery. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_gun#Practical_attempts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_gun#Practical_attempts
- beinstein 8y agoNo maglev and rocket fires at a different time :-)
- gnode 8y agoSorry, I didn't mean to imply this wasn't the case. I've edited this in now.
- rory096 8y agoGiven that the grandparent is presumably Ben Einstein of Bolt VC, an early investor in SpinLaunch, it sounds safe to say it's not using maglev at all. They say the catapult will be a centrifuge spinning inside a vacuum. https://www.crunchbase.com/person/ben-einstein https://www.crunchbase.com/person/ben-einstein https://www.crunchbase.com/funding_round/spinlaunch-convertible-note--39075185#section-investors https://www.crunchbase.com/funding_round/spinlaunch-converti...
- mrfusion 8y agoIt’s surprising how many ways there are to get things into space. Everyone seems to assume we’ve already considered all alternatives and rockets are all we have. Off the top of my head: Providing laser power from the ground station Giant rail gun Launch fountain Launch loop Space elevator Sky hook This spin machine
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoMy favorite: build them there. Or on the Moon etc.
- astrodust 8y agoThe amount of raw material in space is utterly ridiculous. The most boring, irrelevant asteroid probably has more usable raw material in it than the largest mines on Earth.
- WrtCdEvrydy 8y agoRobotic mining company.
- noir_lord 8y agoBeen a trope in scifi for a long time, I remember reading about automated mining systems in a scifi novel back in the 80's. It refined pure metals and then blew gas through them (think of a Carbury's wispa), these where then dropped into the pacific and floated until a ship retrieved them. The idea seemed neat though the line from "We are going to drop a 1000 tonnes of metal into the pacific and that of we are going to drop a 1000 tonnes of metal onto your house" seemed a thin one. It's hard to defend from the bottom of a gravity well against someone at the top of one.
- astrodust 8y agoDropping metal back on Earth presumes that we'd actually care about Earth at that point. There might be so many resources up there that nobody comes back.
- nickparker 8y agoSo, I worked at Hyperloop One for a time, and that experience made me skeptical of the type of complaint I see in this thread. Yes, a high school physics student can tell you the accelerations will be huge unless the loop is too, and a smart one can explain you need a circularizing burn. But, contrary to popular belief investors aren’t total idiots who neglect basic questions. Hard tech companies do face major challenges of course, but they aren’t the ones armchair engineers on HN can point out with 5 minutes thought. So instead of indulging in the “hurrr it’ll never work” superiority stimulus, I’d Like to point out some rays of hope: I don’t think “catapult” means “solid arm on an axle spinning at high speed.” I’m guessing it actually means a large-ish diameter magnetically levitated and accelerated loop. That makes much larger radii possible: at 1 mile you’re looking at ~300g acceleration, 150g at 2 mile. We have loops much bigger than this with much more complex magnetics and vacuum components in our particle accelerators, so this wouldn’t be terrifyingly novel tech. Those accelerations are big but not horribly painful to make a smallsat stand up to. We have guided artillery shells that bear 15,000g launches. I think it’s somewhat feasible. I also think big fully reusable chemical rockets will beat this thing on cost and ease of use, but i don’t think it’ll fail because of armchair physics.
- buvanshak 8y ago> I worked at Hyperloop One for a time, You just lost your credibility.
- sctb 8y agoIf you won't stop breaking the guidelines we'll ban the account. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- buvanshak 8y agoOh fuck off already! This place is full of idiots, that I am not banned already is an insult to me.
- arbie 8y ago
- lev99 8y agoThere is a lot of published raw science on Electromagnetic Linear Motors, with several feasibility studies on Earth to Orbit and Earth to Moon systems. There are several challenges with building on that large, such as building large capacitors, building a structure big enough, and dealing with something that high energy. However, I think we are at a critical point where this might become something we understand how to build. We use the fundamental technology everyday in high speed rail, and we've learned a lot from constructing projects like the LHC and Hyperloop. The Navy is planning on implemented these motors for launch assist on the next generation of aircraft carriers.
- rdl 8y agoI’ve wanted to build a Gerald Bull style space cannon (but the more modern UW RAMAC style) for a long time. Prototype would be $2-5mm, something small which could actually put something decent into orbit around $50mm. I’ve heard there is a group in SoCal which finally got funding to build it.
- growlist 8y agoWould love to know more if you have a link about this group. For some reason I'm fascinated by the space gun concept. Even if it were only used to launch raw materials into space cheaply that could still be a huge boost to space exploration.
- binarymax 8y agoYears ago I backed the Slingatron [0] on Kickstarter, but sadly it was not funded. At first I thought maybe SpinLaunch was a rebrand of HyperV, but that is not the case and its an entirely different group of people. Either way, I'm glad this is getting actual money behind it since it's a very interesting solution, and I hope it "takes off" (sorry). [0] https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/391496725/the-slingatron-building-a-railroad-to-space https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/391496725/the-slingatro...
- carapace 8y agoI've been exploring large-scale structures built using the "Tensegrity" concepts of Bucky Fuller and Ken Snelson. I'm pretty sure you can build really large structures using modern materials (e.g. kevlar and carbon fiber.) Call it "giga-tech" (like nano-tech but scale up instead of down.) One thing in particular that seems feasible is a large floating structure, like a mile-high pyramid, placed on an ocean at the equator, and supporting a launch structure. I think you can make a very large whip-like jointed spaceframe that acts like a catapult to accelerate payloads. By enclosing the outer surface with a membrane you can use solar energy to evaporate water, then condense it at the top of the structure into holding tanks. The mass of the water powers the whip like a trebuchet. (Or you can extract electricity using the principle of Lord Kelvin's Thunderstorm.) I'm pretty sure it would work. No advanced technology or concepts used at all. I don't quite have the chops to do the back-of-envelope math though. Right now I'm working on computer simulations (Finite Element Method.) I'm fortunate that NASA has a program working on tensegrity robots for exploring the surfaces of other planets, and they have released a tool that can simulate tensegrity structures. One other thing, in re: rockets and drag. I can't find a reference right now, but electrifying a rocket with a charge difference from the nose to the tail can significantly reduce drag as the field accelerates the air itself.
- jimbofisher1 8y agoThis is just total lunacy. Have we reached peak VC yet? If not I have a startup that is building a warp drive even though its totally theoretical and the technology to build one is 100+ years away. Throw money at me please.
- sharemywin 8y agoIf it's built on blockchain, I'm in.
- jimbofisher1 8y agoIts built on blockchain using state of the art Deep Learning. Our website is pleasegivememoney.io and all of our founders dropped out of Stanford CS.
- edmundhuber 8y agoI'm very skeptical, of course I'm not as smart or as informed as many other people so what I'm saying might not mean anything. 1) if the idea is to impart all of the kinetic energy needed to get into LEO at once, on the ground, then you are talking ~17,000 MPH worth of KE (though truly, more, because of loss to drag). There's a reason why max-q is an important consideration in the design of space vehicles. The space shuttle reaches max-q at 30K feet, where the density of air is 3x less than at sea level. How do you design your vehicle so that it doesn't turn into dust when it hits 1 ATM at 17,000+ MPH? 2) the centripetal force on the vehicle, prior to launch, will be enormous. So in addition to not deforming and/or burning up the moment the vehicle hits the air, the vehicle also needs to be built sturdily enough to not get crushed while being accelerated. I read Bad Blood a few weekends ago. Holmes hoodwinked investors who wanted to believe that a fairy tale technology could exist, by never publishing or otherwise allowing outside scrutiny of their technology. How is this company different?
- istjohn 8y agoThe slingshot accelerates the rocket up to 5,000 mph according to the article.
- the8472 8y ago> So in addition to not deforming and/or burning up the moment the vehicle hits the air, the vehicle also needs to be built sturdily enough to not get crushed while being accelerated. Since launch mass is less of a concern maybe they can just manufature the satellites differently, e.g. filling the voids with a resin or oil which distributes the forces uniformly.
- shashanoid 8y agoTHE LOGIN DOESNT WORK WTF http://spinlaunch.com/ http://spinlaunch.com/
- ChuckMcM 8y agoI would love to see these guys succeed both because it would be something truly novel, and because I think low cost access to space is going to be critical moving forward. But the physics of getting through the troposphere at 7 to 9 km/sec seem to be really difficult to overcome.
- JohnClark1337 8y ago$40M is a waste of money on a catapult. A Space Trebuchet though....can you imagine?!?!?
- Dowwie 8y agoSeems like a reasonable next step following impeachment.