2 ms·
On one hand, speculations during an ongoing investigation do not do anything good. Ruining someone's career without actually having all of the facts is poor for
by mcguire 8y ago
On one hand, speculations during an ongoing investigation do not do anything good. Ruining someone's career without actually having all of the facts is poor form.
On the other, criticising a collegue for a mistake that is only obvious in retrospect is also poor sportsmanship.
- jessaustin 8y agoAfter you've dropped a bridge on dozens of occupied automobiles, your career is ruined, full stop. No one in TFA claimed that the mistakes were "only obvious in retrospect". All 4 experts independently identified strut 11 as being far too weak, after less than a weekend of study. The original engineer whose firm was paid millions of dollars should have performed the same analysis they did over the weekend, at least.
- mcguire 8y ago1. Accidents happen. If the original engineering firm followed accepted practices then it doesn't matter how quickly someone else found the flaw after the flaw was made evident by the collapse. 2. "After you've dropped a bridge...": Until the investigation is complete, no one has any business assigning responsibility. (In fact, the investigation probably won't assign responsibility; that will be the job of the court system in the subsequent lawsuits.) http://to70.com/why-aviation-safety-experts-dont-talk-about-accidents/ http://to70.com/why-aviation-safety-experts-dont-talk-about-...