3 ms·

Defaults are very important in any UI. An OS that prides itself on usability should have the best default.

wtallis 8y ago
Yes, but you can't assume that having tap to click enabled by default is the best default for the general public. It's way too easy for that to lead to a ton of stray clicks for anyone with impaired sensation or dexterity in their fingers. Apple very often likes to err on the side of making things simpler and more accessible by default while keeping the more powerful features hidden where power users can find them and where they won't distract your grandma. This can be a bit annoying at times for power users, but since those features are available to be turned on it's just a momentary annoyance when you're first setting up a new machine.
- dingo_bat 8y ago
  Agreed, but at least one person came off with a bad experience. That anecdote is worth only that much. But it does indicate a problem.
  - wtallis 8y ago
    You can't please everyone, and the people who are looking for things to complain about are pretty low on the list of who you should be trying to please.
    - dingo_bat 8y ago
      I am not looking for things to complain about. And I doubt the parent was too. It's a genuine issue. As far as not being able to please everyone, how many old people are using macbook pros? Is that number more than the number of regular users who prefer a better touchpad?
      - ericd 8y ago
        It might be annoying for a regular user to have that disabled until they figure out how to enable that, it could be literally unusable for a less capable user to have touch to click enabled. If you're not savvy enough to know that you might be able to disable it, you're probably also unsavvy enough that spurious clicks are disastrous, because you aren't comfortable enough to undo things. I think they may have thought about this a little bit before making their default decisions.
ScottBurson 8y ago
A lot of us think it is the best. I've never liked tap-to-click; I tried it again a year or so ago when my trackpad button went out, and decided it was indeed unusable — too many unintended clicks. (I replaced the trackpad.) Anyway, "the clicking thing is much slower than tapping" is just not true if you're used to clicking.

Yes, but you can't assume that having tap to click enabled by default is the best default for the general public. It's way too easy for that to lead to a ton of stray clicks for anyone with impaired sensation or dexterity in their fingers. Apple very often likes to err on the side of making things simpler and more accessible by default while keeping the more powerful features hidden where power users can find them and where they won't distract your grandma. This can be a bit annoying at times for power users, but since those features are available to be turned on it's just a momentary annoyance when you're first setting up a new machine.

dingo_bat 8y ago
Agreed, but at least one person came off with a bad experience. That anecdote is worth only that much. But it does indicate a problem.
- wtallis 8y ago
  You can't please everyone, and the people who are looking for things to complain about are pretty low on the list of who you should be trying to please.
  - dingo_bat 8y ago
    I am not looking for things to complain about. And I doubt the parent was too. It's a genuine issue. As far as not being able to please everyone, how many old people are using macbook pros? Is that number more than the number of regular users who prefer a better touchpad?
    - ericd 8y ago
      It might be annoying for a regular user to have that disabled until they figure out how to enable that, it could be literally unusable for a less capable user to have touch to click enabled. If you're not savvy enough to know that you might be able to disable it, you're probably also unsavvy enough that spurious clicks are disastrous, because you aren't comfortable enough to undo things. I think they may have thought about this a little bit before making their default decisions.

ScottBurson 8y ago

A lot of us think it is the best. I've never liked tap-to-click; I tried it again a year or so ago when my trackpad button went out, and decided it was indeed unusable — too many unintended clicks. (I replaced the trackpad.) Anyway, "the clicking thing is much slower than tapping" is just not true if you're used to clicking.