4 ms·
What about pictures of other crimes involving children, like dead and mutilated children. The parents can be re-victimized by seeing their dead children online
by megous 8y ago
What about pictures of other crimes involving children, like dead and mutilated children. The parents can be re-victimized by seeing their dead children online again and again, potentially. If the child survived, it would surely be triggering to see themselves suffering so horribly.
Should people posessing such pictures be treated as harshly as people posessing cp? They certainly are not right now.
I guess intent is different on the production side. It's usually reporting (but often times people just sharing pictures they received from someone, without any censorship or much verification). But what do we know why people want to posess such pictures. It's a picture/video of a horrific crime involving a child, perhaps even more horrific than most CP. I mean how can you compare a child being tickled inappropriately for example with a child intentionally burned by chemicals until it slowly drowns to death because of pulmonary edema.
Sometimes society's rules are hard do make sense of if you try to make sense of them rationally.
- allenz 8y agoLaws are a balance of interests. There are legitimate reasons to show violent crimes in a documentary, work of art, or political commentary, which balance against the harm. There are no reasons to show child pornography. Sexual abuse emphasizes dynamics of objectification, humiliation, powerlessness. I'd argue that victims respond more strongly to pictures of sexual abuse than to pictures of physical violence. Wikipedia says that a million children have been abused to produce child pornography, whereas there are few instances of violence to produce pictures of violence. In this sense, child pornography is inseparable from the crime, whereas with violence, there is a distinction between the crime and the documentation. That said, I do sympathize with the view that sentences for the possession of child pornography are too harsh, especially when viewing pedophilia as a mental disorder. I strongly support efforts to make therapy more accessible, such as https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prevention_Project_Dunkelfeld https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prevention_Project_Dunkelfeld.
- megous 8y agoYes, there's a component that some people are attracted to viewing CP, thus there's incentive to produce it. This component is probably not that present in an addiction to gore material. People can be sensitive to the way the material was produced and react differently to accidental/documentary, staged voluntary, or staged involuntary recordings. If you search online you'll find accounts of people being horrified, yet attracted to gore. Psychology of these things is quite interesting.