2 ms·
Ask HN: Why are contrarian anecdotes so alluring?
Every single time there's a discussion on HN about how "X helps to achieve Y" someone will say, without fail, "I tried X and nothing happened", or "I tried X and all this terrible stuff happened".
They'll say this in response to a weak study. They'll say it in response to a large, well run, meta-analysis of other large well run studies.
I've probably done it.
Why is the contrarian anecdote so common? WHy do we feel the need to drop these into discussion?
- cimmanom 8y agoProbably because the human brain evolved long before there were any large, well-run meta-analyses of scientific studies. 50,000 years ago, if someone made a claim, and you had experience to the contrary, it was important to your tribe to hear the counter-evidence, lest they start making decisions without all the currently-available information. Our brains may rationally absorb "this effect holds true for 95% of participants, and if it doesn't for you, that's within the range of normalcy (the other 5%) but doesn't invalidate the findings". But our instincts aren't as nuanced.