3 ms·
The author does not explain why govt-sponsored nanotech research elsewhere (Russia, China) turned out just as fruitless and the same kind of rebranding enterpri
by varjag 16y ago
The author does not explain why govt-sponsored nanotech research elsewhere (Russia, China) turned out just as fruitless and the same kind of rebranding enterprise as in USA.
- hga 16y agoA) Have they really tried Drexler style nanotech? I don't know, but I've simply not heard of any place else trying it (although there's some interesting stuff being done in Switzerland). Certainly the detractors would triumph any such failures. B) China does a lot more cargo cult science than real science, due at least in part to the incentive structures (look at the many recent HN items on the subject; it's become a major issue for any practicing scientist). For that matter, true innovations coming out of Japan are pretty rare due to their seniority system; e.g. until very recently every native of Japan that won a Nobel had to leave the country to do his research (which is a form or permanent self-exile, setting the barrier pretty high...). This is not to say that all furreniers are incapable of Real Science, just that it's a lot more rare than one might think. There are reasons US research universities are rated as the best in the world, with only a few Western ones (mostly in the U.K.?) giving them competition.
- varjag 16y agoI don't know. Stakes are certainly high for canonical Drexler type nanotech. You'd figure a lot of the governments would've loved to have an edge there, if it was possible or within short leap from current technological base? Government taking charge for research certainly worked for the space race. Among all the countless grants and fellowships in nanotech you'd hope it would yield at least something resembling the original vision, at this point. I sort of can relate to your point B, and perhaps it's not even just the Asian nations.
- hga 16y agoStakes are high, but that doesn't mean the almost always conservative establishments of countries will treat it that seriously (this is particularly unlikely in Japan as noted). The space race was a combination of re-purposing military hardware (at least for us, only the Saturn boosters didn't start their life as such, I think the same is essentially true for the Soviets) for short term term political advantage. We were claiming to be the most technologically advanced system, yet the Soviets were the first to orbit a satellite (due to internal US bureaucratic turf fighting) and the first to put a man in orbit. To convince other countries that our system was the best we had to match and exceed the Soviet program. A good counter example is how other countries only got really serious about atomic weapons after we used two in such a public fashion. Both the general concept (E = mc^2) and the specific method (fission of heavy isotopes) had been around for quite some time; it took the prod of war to actually do it. You'd hope some grant money would go this way, but remember that the existing chemistry etc. establishments are already entrenched in the system and good at getting grant money. In the US they had no trouble spending 'nanotech' money for their usual pursuits. Also don't forget that this paradigm shift is a threat to the way they've learned to do things. Never underestimate how far powerful people will go when they are faced with what they view as an existential threat. Look at how willing Nobelist Smalley was to flatly lie about what Drexler was proposing and his first choice of a forum, one notorious for not allowing those attacked to respond, for an example of this. As for point B, it's not just the Asian nations: I don't know about their current status, but it was Brazil's scientific establishment that Feynman viewed up close and personally during an extended visit that prompted him to formulate the cargo cult science concept. Looking at where Nobelists actually did their work would be one way of taking a stab at the question.