6 ms·
Detroit's Mayor Mike Duggan wants a subway to run from the airport to downtown. He said he's waiting for Boring Co's project to finish in LA so he can check wi
by rmason 8y ago
Detroit's Mayor Mike Duggan wants a subway to run from the airport to downtown. He said he's waiting for Boring Co's project to finish in LA so he can check with the mayor to see if it's worthwhile.
https://www.detroitnews.com/story/news/local/detroit-city/2018/06/12/mayor-mike-duggan-elon-musk-underground-railway-tunnel-detroit-metropolitan-airport/695486002/ https://www.detroitnews.com/story/news/local/detroit-city/20...
Meanwhile Chicago's mayor, Rahm Emmanuel, just slipped ahead of him in line ;<).
- cozzyd 8y agoDetroit can probably handle its demand for airport-downtown travel with a bus lane on one of its many freeways, if the freeways are even congested enough to warrant that... In fact, bus lanes on freeways would probably be a better solution for most of The Boring Company's applications...
- dx034 8y agoBuses on dedicated lanes have found to be cheaper and as fast as subways in some cities. But they're not as prestigious and it's harder to ensure that the next government won't destroy the system by opening it up for other vehicles. Trains make sense for longer distances (more efficient) but in cities, buses work as well and can be used more flexibly.
- skgoa 8y agoThat's not entirely what public transport companies have found. Busses don't scale as well as using entire trains. I have seen a bus route replaced by a tram, because they had to send double-length busses at every few minutes. Which in practice meant that you would see two or three of those busses arrive at the same time. A well-planned public transport system will use a mix of busses of diverse sizes in conjunction with trains/trams for trunk routes.
- rsynnott 8y agoThe big problem with fully segregated bus lanes vs subways is that they have a lower peak capacity. However, this Boring company thing has a peak described capacity of only 2k/hour, lower than even a BRT/segregated lane bus system. Real subways have far higher capacities, obviously.
- cozzyd 8y agoThere are reasons for trains over buses (like increased capacity and lower dwell time), but neither of those are important to the system that Musk is envisioning.
- JackCh 8y agoI've heard some people cynically suggest that stalling public transportation projects is the true objective of the Boring Company, similar in motivation to the General Motors streetcar conspiracy. But I'm pretty skeptical of this since Tesla sells luxury cars; public transit seems unlikely to threaten their business.
- ComradeTaco 8y agoI don't think Musk's goal is to destroy public transit, but things like the hyperloop have been used as a bludgeon to attack high speed rail initiatives. [1] (https://www.investors.com/politics/editorials/hyperloop-development-california-high-speed-rail-delays/ https://www.investors.com/politics/editorials/hyperloop-deve...)
- noobermin 8y agoIt may not be his goal but he has certainly spoken of his dislike of public transit.
- TomMarius 8y agoI agree with him. Public transport doesn't scale well, doesn't completely replace individual transport and is uncomfortable for everyone. Optimal (not the current system) individual transportation is much better.
- majewsky 8y ago> Public transport doesn't scale well Much better than individual transport. Just compare the space taken up by a bus with 40 seats, with 20 individual cars (I'm generously assuming an average two persons per car). > doesn't completely replace individual transport That was never the intention of public transport. It aims to supply the majority of rides. > is uncomfortable for everyone. Aaah, I get it. You're from the US.
- 8y ago
- lvh 8y agoDetroit’s connection between airport and downtown is a complete disaster compared to either Chicago airport. A high speed rail link would make a ton more sense there.