4 ms·
I wonder how conscious is this process? Do people really tell themselves things like "aha, I'll show them that I am rich buying something I don't need that's e
by rdtsc 16y ago
I wonder how conscious is this process?
Do people really tell themselves things like "aha, I'll show them that I am rich buying something I don't need that's expensive" or does the desire to buy something extravagant and expensive just pop into their head out of nowhere and they are just compelled to do it.
Also, what is the strength of the desire to signal among all groups? Perhaps a poor person has a stronger desire to signal that they are rich than a rich person to signal that they are not poor. I think that's the second axis -- how much one signals.
If it is conscious, where does the refusal to signal fall into? Like the author mentions, it would seem that an intellectually honest person should rationally analyze themselves, and steer clear of this kind of trap.
- Herring 16y agoI've read only snippets of their articles on signalling, but I think it's mainly issues of self & identity. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narcissism_of_small_differences http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narcissism_of_small_differences
- nkurz 16y agoDifferent levels of behaviour are associated with different levels of consciousness. For your example of conspicuous consumption, all the crosses seem possible. In my social circles, I'd guess that in general the most common are to "buy unconsciously" and to "avoid consciously". It would probably depend on your specific example. I wouldn't think of it as a trap, though. It's more of a situational awareness. People will react differently based on the signals you send. Is the trap to signal consciously or unconsciously? Because consciously not signalling might turn out to be the trap to avoid. But then again, so might any of the three other combinations
- timinman 16y agoI read somewhere that hipsters almost universally deny being hipsters.
- sethg 16y agoI assume it’s a process of “the people I hang out with, who are in my economic class, are all driving BMWs and Lexuses, and I feel silly parking my Subaru next to their cars”.
- sesqu 16y agoSome of it is definitely conscious. In particular, a certain class of people "trying to break in" consciously spend above their means in order to be perceived as having the means. I have not encountered a whole lot of evidence that this works - I only know of it from the many cases where it didn't work, or worked just long enough to allow them to fail to express other qualities the "in" crowd has. Similarly, a lot of the "new rich" commentary suggests a desire to flaunt success, Trump style, because the individual is acutely aware of how different their circumstances have become and wish to let others know they are no longer in their previous position. They are signalling that they have, in fact, "broken in". However, the qualities they are signalling are generally not signalled by the natural members of the group, who merely express them. These members may unconsciously signal other things, such as slang. In other words, those who are aware of different levels may signal a level consciously. Others will not, beyond expressing the qualities that define them as of the level. A curious person might be contrarian, while an experienced one could be simplistic. Here, the "above average" one will be expressing, while the "intelligent" one is applying and the pragmatic one would be signalling (authority). Conscious signals tend to be hollow by necessity, and targeted at a specific level.
- araneae 16y agoWell, my beliefs are pretty meta-contrarian, and I think it stems from a desire to be different. So those old-rich may look at the new rich, feel disgusted that they may possibly be put in the same "bucket" as them, and try to find some way to distinguish themselves from them. That's how I went from Democrat to Libertarian. And then Libertarian to libertarian. And then libertarian to ?. If I were going to be less self-effacing, I could also say that any time my beliefs are held by a large number of people, I start to question them, because it's not possible for a large number of people to both agree and be perfectly correct...
- jbooth 16y ago++ to you for the self-awareness. Personally I saw how libertarian arguments were just so fun to make and just so unworkable in any real world situation and skipped the whole trap, stayed a democrat. But I've made my own meta contrarian points (trying to tell my liberal friends that the iraq war was a good idea) and almost always been borne out wrong by reality. Turns out if your motivations veers from "truth" to "it feels good to make this argument", you're gonna steer yourself wrong.