10 ms·
> The problem is, how do you build a back door that can only be used by people with valid (and just) warrants? That's an interesting technical problem. A lot o
by tzs 8y ago
> The problem is, how do you build a back door that can only be used by people with valid (and just) warrants?
That's an interesting technical problem. A lot of people dismiss it as impossible out of hand, but they are underestimating what you can do with modern cryptography.
You make it a distributed back door that requires several independent third parties to cooperate to use it.
You choose the third parties so that no particular warrant seeker will be able to get enough power or influence over enough of the third parties to force them to enable the back door unless they think the use is valid and just. (You can actually design it so that the warrant seeker does not know who the third parties are).
Some aspects of this may be too complicated to be practical, but it is not impossible.
- zelon88 8y agoKnowing how our government works they would just get tired of leaving each other voicemails and put their private keys on a network share or something.
- olliej 8y agoNo, having worked on crypto I feel confident saying that the smart people, especially those who do understand crypto, know, and state, that it cannot be done. All solution fundamentally boil down to someone has the keys required to decrypt all your content. This is ignoring the other technical costs (now your service has to record all ephemeral keys as well). It doesn’t matter /who/ has that decryption key, the requirement is that access to the key is guarded only by policy. You also resort to “with a warrant” but a NSL is effectively a warrant, and I’m fairly sure the DPRC has “warrants”. Who gets to request those keys? The position of the us government is that they have the right to access data from people in other countries, so can they provide a warrant to access that data? Can Germany ask for the data for someone in the US? What if someone travelled through another country - can that country now access those keys? Note these all questions regarding /legitimate/ access, I’m completely ignoring police officers looking up people they stopped and stealing nudes, of people stealing the information and using that information to steal money, stalking, etc I am sick and tired of people who say “modern cryptography is amazing, so it must be able to fulfill my unicorn dreams”. Either stop claiming nonsense or provide a prove that it is possible by designing a system that does what you say must be possible.
- tzs 8y agoBriefly, use a secret sharing protocol to distribute the device key to 500 lawyers around the world from countries other than the country the device holder resides in, with 400 key shares needed to reconstruct the device key. A requester can get the device key if he can convince 400 of the 500 lawyers that his request is legitimate according to whatever the criteria was that the lawyers agreed to when they agreed to become key share holders.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoYour argument fell apart when you said "secret". What do you do to prevent widespread abuse when the secret gets out?
- davidgay 8y agoper-device key.
- mcny 8y agoWho holds the per device key? If someone holds all the per device keys (or parts of the per device key) you've painted a bulls eye on their face. In all honesty, I cannot trust the US government with secrets like this because I don't see us being willing to secure it at the same level that we secure our nukes. And dear lord even that level of security likely won't be enough to fend off internal and external threats.
- mirimir 8y agoI'm sure that's a reference to Shamir's Secret Sharing Scheme,[0] which is hardly a secret. 0) http://point-at-infinity.org/ssss/ http://point-at-infinity.org/ssss/
- fauigerzigerk 8y agoWhat law would those lawyers apply and who would select them?
- 8y ago
- natch 8y ago>several independent third parties to cooperate Your foolishly conceived system does have any way to ensure that the several parties are not corrupt or evil. You would need to solve that problem first. Assuming it is solved does not work. In the meantime, devices need to be designed to protect the human rights of users.