3 ms·
I was under the impression that quantum entanglement could provide perfect privacy across a connection, as it would be obvious whether the line communication wa
by colordrops 8y ago
I was under the impression that quantum entanglement could provide perfect privacy across a connection, as it would be obvious whether the line communication was intercepted.
- lallysingh 8y agoBut you'd need an entangled pair with everyone you want to communicate with.
- whatshisface 8y agoYou'd just have to organize daily deliveries from the Entanglement Man.
- krapp 8y agoChances are the Entanglement Man makes 12.00/hr, has to provide his own car and pees into a bottle to make quota.
- bArray 8y agoNo, you would just need to get an entangled key from a distributor. Once you can communicate with one well connected and trusted actor, you're good to go. Think more like web security certificates...
- lallysingh 8y agoBut how do you know you have the right entagled peer? How's that different than any other out of band key exchange?
- n4r9 8y agoThat's true for the E91 protocol, but for BB84 you only need a (public) quantum channel through which Alice can send states to Bob.
- leetbulb 8y agoFrom what I understand, quantum entanglement is used in "secure communications" as a key exchange (more of a distribution, as a third-party is required to distribute the entangled photons) (QKD - See: BB84 for example). Following this key exchange phase, normal encryption algorithms are used over traditional infrastructure. This is already being done in real environments. In a real world implementation, you are using this as a key stream, of which interceptions can be detected by certain loss characteristics.
- colordrops 8y agoThe problem is that normal encryption is complicated and often has vulnerabilities. Perhaps we could find a way to transport an entangled photon down some channel?
- hannob 8y agoThis is the impression they want you to have. There are a few caveats: * You need a direct connection with a limit in length. This means effectively you can't have wifi, mobile internet or anything like that. You also probably can't use it to have a connection between the US and Europe. Calling that a "quantum internet" is... only possible if you have no idea what the term "internet" means. * You need an existing authenticated channel or be vulnerable to man in the middle attacks. The quantum key distribution schemes always assume this already exists, but never care to explain where they got it from.
- dTal 8y ago>You need an existing authenticated channel or be vulnerable to man in the middle attacks Isn't this theoretically unavoidable for all forms of encryption? You need some way of distinguishing your intended communication partner, because the best that any protocol could do is establish a secure link with whoever is on the other end of the line.