4 ms·
The technical aspects aren't the problem. The political and social aspects are. What does Apple do if they have this capability and China puts pressure on them
by CydeWeys 8y ago
The technical aspects aren't the problem. The political and social aspects are.
What does Apple do if they have this capability and China puts pressure on them to unencrypt some information on Chinese "dissidents"? China has incredible leverage over Apple, seeing as how all their devices are built there. Would Apple dare resist these requests from Chinese national law enforcement agencies?
Better to not have this ability at all, and thus never be put into this precarious situation.
- wallace_f 8y agoInteresting that you looked to China foran example of a bad outcome. Ordinary police here in the states already misuse the privileged access they've been given, such as to supposedly private personal details to stalk romantic interests, personal enemies, business competitors, etc.[1] 1-https://apnews.com/699236946e3140659fff8a2362e16f43/ap-across-us-police-officers-abuse-confidential-databases https://apnews.com/699236946e3140659fff8a2362e16f43/ap-acros...
- Veedrac 8y ago> The technical aspects aren't the problem. The political and social aspects are. With this I agree completely.
- rsyntax 8y agoJust to add. Looking at the current political state surrounding the Russian collusion investigation. It's not a stretch that Trump would not use this against his political enemies or "fake new media". And look at what his supporters have done with FBI agents that had an affair with private text messages. Trump isn't the first of his kind nor will s/he be the last.
- ataturk 8y agoThe truth is, these companies don't care about Chinese dissidents. Real people fighting for real freedom deserve our support and respect, but Google especially has demonstrated their disdain for anyone who stands up against the Chinese government, and I don't figure Apple is any better. We need to demand our rights and demand that people around the world are brought up to our level because the alternative is us ending up at their level.
- lern_too_spel 8y ago> Better to not have this ability at all, and thus never be put into this precarious situation. Apple has this ability now, by installing an OS that allows bruteforcing the pin.
- dwaite 8y agoApple cant do this passively/on demand, as upgrading the OS or Secure Enclave requires the user passcode. Of course the new OS/Secure Enclave firmware could remove this restriction, but generally these sorts of requests are reactionary