3 ms·
I have trouble calling it a paradox, because there is nothing that needs explaining in my view. Just throw in the fact that known fudge factors are important,
by btilly 8y ago
I have trouble calling it a paradox, because there is nothing that needs explaining in my view. Just throw in the fact that known fudge factors are important, and throw in the fact that there are more fudge factors that we don't know.
For example the traditional Drake equation doesn't include as a major factor "large moon that stabilizes the axial tilt over evolutionary time". And yet that seems to be needed and at least somewhat rare.
The traditional Drake equation doesn't include as a major factor "life not wiped out by a supernova over evolutionary time". And yet per http://earthsky.org/astronomy-essentials/supernove-distance http://earthsky.org/astronomy-essentials/supernove-distance there are estimates that this might happen on average once per 15 million years. From the Cambrian explosion to the present is around 540 million years. The odds of that forbearance is on the order of 7 billion to 1 against. How much does THAT change the Drake equation?
- jobigoud 8y agoIt doesn't have to include these specifics. They are just sub-factors contributing to higher level factors. Your first is covered by "fl, the fraction of those planets that actually develop life", and your second is covered by "fi, the fraction of planets bearing life on which intelligent, civilized life, has developed". What you are saying seems to be the same as OP. It's not a paradox because the chances are insignificant, so we are indeed alone.
- stephenwinter2 8y agoI agree, I also can't see a paradox in terms of nature. And I would like to add an aspect of sociology (sociology is rarely discussed at this topic): Given mankind's industrialization period and decline of the ecosystem is normal it takes longer to get to an exoplanet than to ruin it. - So, what interstellar space travel really would be is this: The living mankind on Earth gives up itself and its home planet to spread the genes of those who plan its demise. http://www.hashsign.eu/html/blog/dominance/hadfield-hawking-eugenics-and-interstellar-space-colonization.html http://www.hashsign.eu/html/blog/dominance/hadfield-hawking-... My answer to the Fermi Paradox is this: These bastards shouldn't get away with it.