6 ms·
Lobbying the government to restore net neutrality is far cheaper than building out an ISP. Also, 5G is coming by the end of this year with at least two provide
by jedberg 8y ago
Lobbying the government to restore net neutrality is far cheaper than building out an ISP.
Also, 5G is coming by the end of this year with at least two providers (Verizon and T-Mobile) and once that happens, ATT and Comcast won't have as much stranglehold on the ISP market, so NN may not matter anymore.
- kec 8y agoI don't see how 5G changes anything. Wireless providers were exempt from net neutrality even when it was in force and have a long history of tiered usage and throttling.
- ab071c41 8y agoI think the idea is better fixed WISP options which could potentially replace cable internet. If Verizon/T-Mobile suddenly have a home internet option based on 5G, then Comcast gets competition.
- twothamendment 8y agoThat is tough to do. I lived in a city where there wasn't any cable and the DSL sucked. A few WISPs were the only real game in town. They weren't bad - until evening when everyone started to stream. They upgraded several times over the years, but it is still a rough business to try to broadcast out so many streams at once. I had it pretty good because my WISP had a tower on my roof and I was hard wired to their backhaul. For everyone else in the neighborhood it was slower.
- haikuginger 8y agoHaving wireless providers who are able to provide landline-level speeds means that many markets will go from having one or maybe two real ISP options to having three or four. Competition means that if the benefits of net neutrality are desirable, customers will prefer an ISP (wireless or otherwise) that provides those benefits. Of course, most actual counterexamples to net neutrality are seen as positives (free Netflix or Hulu with usage not counted towards a data cap) rather than negatives, so it might not work out.
- 0xffff2 8y agoAre these providers actually going to compete with landline ISP's? My landline ISPs over the last couple of years have had monthly data caps ranging from 256gb to 1tb. My cell plan currently throttles me after I exceed 6gb... That's two orders of magnitude that my wireless provider would have to increase the cap in order to compete with the landline ISP.
- rayiner 8y agoThe plan appears to be, yes: https://www.pcmag.com/news/357374/verizon-no-4g-level-data-caps-for-5g-home-service https://www.pcmag.com/news/357374/verizon-no-4g-level-data-c.... Verizon execs are throwing around 5G caps in that ballpark.
- JustSomeNobody 8y agoThat's a tiny ballpark: > During a roundtable, VP of network support Mike Haberman, some other Verizon folks, and the assembled journalists agreed that an average data cap in the vicinity of 180GB/month would satisfy the average consumer. > "That shouldn't be a problem with 5G. What does 4K video use? Think about how many 4K TVs you can put on a service that's a true 1 gigabit to your house," Haberman said. I don't see that 180GB lasting long at all...
- rayiner 8y agoThe average Netflix user watches 40-50 hours per month, and its going down: https://techcrunch.com/2017/12/11/netflix-users-collectively-watched-1-billion-hours-of-content-per-week-in-2017 https://techcrunch.com/2017/12/11/netflix-users-collectively.... Netflix says 7GB/hour for 4K (~350 gigabytes), but HEVC will halve that number. That's under 180GB, and that's assuming all streaming is 4K, which is far from the case.
- 0xffff2 8y agoThat's also just for one person on Netflix. Now add a roommate, Youtube, Twitch, general overhead (email, web browsing, app updates, etc).
- cirgue 8y ago> Lobbying the government to restore net neutrality is far cheaper than building out an ISP. Also, I suspect that state-level legislative initiatives are going to be much easier to win than trying to sue executive agencies.
- pooya13 8y agoJust wondering. Would it matter if they win on state level if the traffic is slowed down on its route in another state? Also do the states even have the authority if the federal government wants to enforce the states to get rid of NN?
- jedberg 8y agoState level matters because if you for example get NN restored in California, New York, and Texas, it's cheaper for the ISP to do NN everywhere then to try and figure out all the traffic destined to or coming from a customer in California, New York, or Texas.
- woah 8y agoLast mile is really the only thing in question here. 1. Because that's where there's a real lack of competition 2. Because traffic going long range is already "slowed down" even with net neutrality. If you are paying a CDN, they likely have paid for higher priority "leased lines" between their data centers, while the rest of the traffic goes over the "regular internet" (keep in mind that the "leased line" and the "regular internet" here are probably the same fiber, the distinction is legal, because under net neutrality carriers are still allowed to charge differently for "leased lines")