3 ms·
So the quote at the end is Tesla's "you're holding it wrong" moment, eh? It reminds me of stubborn developers that blow off bad UI design with "they're not supp
by mikestew 8y ago
So the quote at the end is Tesla's "you're holding it wrong" moment, eh? It reminds me of stubborn developers that blow off bad UI design with "they're not supposed to do that". Well, fact of the matter is, users do do that, so account for it. Fact of the matter is, Tesla, your advertising gives users the impression that they can practically take a nap with Autopilot on (because it has the hardware for fully-automated driving, amirite?), so don't be pulling out the fine print about proper use of Autopilot.
To a more general point, when driving a car I should not have to ask, "is it going to work this time?" I hit the brake pedal, I have a high degree of confidence that the car will scrub off speed. I hit the gas, I don't worry that it will go (except in our old VW). I set Autopilot, I expect that it won't plow into the back of car in front of it. Whoops, scratch that last one. Instead, I'll constantly be wondering if it's going to do its job.
- notlob 8y agoIn risk management for the medical devices I’ve worked on, we account for users and patients not following instructions during the design process. “You’re holding it wrong” is literally something we account for. From my perspective Tesla has been baffling, especially so considering the highly involved CEO is aware that people use his company’s product contra to the instructions for use.
- blatherard 8y agoHere's a video from a few years ago of Elon Musk doing exactly what they're saying not to do: https://youtu.be/MO0vdNNzwxk?t=2m https://youtu.be/MO0vdNNzwxk?t=2m
- dpark 8y ago> Well, fact of the matter is, users do do that, so account for it. Of course they do that. The functionality is completely useless if you still have to fully engage with driving the car. Cruise control is useful for resting the driver’s leg. This doesn’t require a reduction in attention. Partial automation’s benefit comes specifically from relieving the demand for attention. To turn around and say that you still have to be fully attentive and in full control is to say that the automation is entirely useless.