3 ms·
"educational outcomes in right to work states aren't any better than outcomes in states where teachers unions have collectively bargained contracts" Do you hav
by gojomo 16y ago
"educational outcomes in right to work states aren't any better than outcomes in states where teachers unions have collectively bargained contracts"
Do you have a reference that compares states and controls for outcomes with respect to income, general educational levels, and other confounding factors?
Using state-level averages for comparisons can be misleading, due to Simpson's Paradox. For example, people in wealthier states are more likely to vote Democratic. But if you used that to determine that wealthier people are more likely to vote Democratic, you'd be wrong. In each state individually, and nationwide, wealthier people are less likely to vote Democratic than poorer people (until you get to a small number of the very-rich).
Also, I don't think any reformer is obsessed with collective bargaining and right-to-work laws as the root of the problem. Rather, reformers want accountability, choice, experimentation, and competition. Public teachers' unions consistently and effectively oppose those, even in right-to-work states. Unless their power is reduced, even in right-to-work states, many of the most promising reforms and experiments can't even be tried.
- sachinag 16y agoSadly, there's very little research controlling for these factors. http://www.hepg.org/hep/Book/5 http://www.hepg.org/hep/Book/5 has a collection of papers that addresses some of this on the periphery.