4 ms·
The Drake equation is the epitome of garbage in garbage out. Trying to draw a line using a single data point. There was recent news from NASA about the discov
by jandrese 8y ago
The Drake equation is the epitome of garbage in garbage out. Trying to draw a line using a single data point.
There was recent news from NASA about the discovery of organic molecules on Mars and the possibility of life there at some point in the past. Discovery that life once existed on Mars would blow up the assumptions in the Drake equation.
As for the Fermi paradox I'm still of the opinion that its solution is simple but depressing: Interstellar travel is so difficult that by the time you're capable of it you don't need it anymore, and even when you're capable of it you still don't get very far outside of your stellar neighborhood. Unlimited power systems, reactionless drives, and FTL travel (or even high-c travel) are depressingly impossible. And then the cold hand of entropy and the aggregate chance of disaster make it extremely dangerous to even attempt. Basically without Sci-Fi propulsion/power you end up traveling at an interstellar snail's pace, and the longer the trip the more likely it is that a random meteorite smashes through your vessel, or you simply run out of spare parts and materials to make them, and the amount of fuel you need to just keep the lights on becomes enormous.
If you can build a starship that can travel between solar systems with our current understanding of physics, then you can build orbital colonies for basically unlimited living space much much easier. For one, they can be powered by solar cells instead of needing to carry fuel. It's not like we are going to run out of raw materials either. Even restricting yourself to the belt the amount of material available would last basically indefinitely. Worst case you can start breaking up moons.
So even in a universe full of life everybody is alone. Especially if you think about how genetic algorithms tend to get hung up on local maxima, so lots of planets waste millions of years with dumb dinosaurs with no space program or radio telescopes.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoAlso, VR. I already fear the future of humanity is not exploring strange new worlds, but creating virtual ones, and converting the solar system into more computronium. (And the weird thing about that is that I feel it's a bad thing for some reason, but I can't articulate a coherent argument against it.)
- greglindahl 8y agoThere are a bunch of scifi novels that explore the issue, and most of them feature bad things that result.
- jandrese 8y agoTo be fair, if it turned out all hunky dory then the novel wouldn't be very exciting. Sometimes the downsides are rather contrived.
- strkek 8y agoAs long as humans continue to be like we have been so far, i.e. with the mentality of destroying our own planet and not caring about it, or committing crimes like kidnapping, etc... as long as there are individuals like that, every time we humans learn something new, things will inevitably turn way more scarier. Whether it's colonizing other planets or making a full-dive VR; just thinking about the time when we can do any of these things gives me a headache.
- jcranmer 8y agoOnly two variables of the Drake equation can be meaningfully estimated: rate of star formation and fraction of stars with planets. The number of life-supporting planets per star is surprisingly ill-defined (what number is that for Sol?). All of the other variables are basically knobs that let you control what you want the answer to be. > There was recent news from NASA about the discovery of organic molecules on Mars and the possibility of life there at some point in the past. It should be pointed out that the organic molecules in question are known to be created by abiotic processes. > As for the Fermi paradox I'm still of the opinion that its solution is simple but depressing: Interstellar travel is so difficult that by the time you're capable of it you don't need it anymore, and even when you're capable of it you still don't get very far outside of your stellar neighborhood. Well, there's an even more depressing possibility: interstellar communication itself is effectively impossible, let alone travel. Any beam will spread out over a larger and larger radius, so even the most focused laser beams will become too weak to detect within I think a few hundred light years, so we're not even talking about trying to find aliens in the galaxy, we're talking about trying to find aliens in the nearest stars.
- jandrese 8y agoIt doesn't help that we have a giant noise source in the middle of our solar system that shoots the noise floor through the roof when you're trying to detect laser comms over light years. Plus, even at lightspeed you're talking multi-year roundtrips to our nearest interstellar neighbors. Our entire history of radio emissions has only made it to around 500 solar systems currently. Even if someone was listening and responded immediately the response probably wouldn't have made it back to Earth yet.