5 ms·
I have a feeling that, if I ever applied to YCombinator, my application would end up in the wastebasket the moment they caught a whiff of the fact that I have a
by pg 19y ago
I have a feeling that, if I ever applied to YCombinator, my application would end up in the wastebasket the moment they caught a whiff of the fact that I have a wife and kids.
We don't ask on the application form if people have kids, nor as far as I can recall have we asked anyone in an interview. The reason most of the people we fund don't have kids is simply that most of the people who apply don't have kids.
- jsrn 19y ago> [...] most of the people who apply don't have kids. how do you know if you don't ask?
- pg 19y agoTrue, I'm guessing based on the demographic similarity between the people we accept (whose circumstances I do eventually learn about) and applicants as a whole. But the median applicant does seem to be about the same as the median company we fund: a pair of guys about 25 years old.
- tptacek 19y agoNot for nothing, but for a hiring manager, asking this question is a firing offense. So is age, marital status, religion, or even any question about place of residence apart from "are you capable of being on-site during core hours". From a lot of unfortunate experience: tech people suck at following these rules.
- petercooper 19y agoIt's more unfortunate that a few bad apples in the past have made these laws necessary in the first place. Asking someone about their life is hardly a crime, but our governments seem to have no problem making it so. Score another point against a good employer / employee relationship.
- tptacek 19y agoHow could it possibly be relevant to your hiring decision how old someone is, or what neighborhood they live in?
- petercooper 19y agoYou can guess someone's age within a few years at an interview if you wanted to discriminate, so blocking a mention of age is naive. You could also work it out in most cases from the dates given on the resume (unless it becomes illegal to learn about a candidate's education or work history - which wouldn't surprise me to be honest). You could see what neighborhood someone lives in because that will also be typically included on a resume too. Why would you hire someone who can't even put their street address on their resume? Sure, a street address doesn't have much significance to /most/ hiring decisions, although if you knew a candidate would have a 100 mile commute each day, choosing someone who lived around the corner would make a lot of sense if the job required call-out or easy access to the office. And so it goes. You'll see someone's race at interview. You can probably even figure out if someone's married (presence of a ring). It seems crazy to make it illegal to ask these questions. Instead, it should be law that it's optional for the candidate to ANSWER them.
- ks 19y ago> Instead, it should be law that it's optional for the candidate to ANSWER them. Isn't every question optional? It's not like you go to jail if you don't answer a question. It's not a good strategy, but AFAIK it is legal
- jcl 19y agoInstead, it should be law that it's optional for the candidate to ANSWER them. That opens another can of worms. Any refusal to answer implies something to hide, which would be an immediate red flag.
- tptacek 19y agoThis line of reasoning seems nonsensical. There are no non-optional interview questions. But all questions asked during an interview are used to discriminate between candidates; that's the point of an interview. How do you ask a candidate what their age is without discriminating based on age? If you're not discriminating on age, why on earth would you ask the question?
- jcl 19y agoIt's been noted in the past that Y Combinator in fact does ask for founders' ages. Presumably it can skirt the hiring laws because it is funding a company, not employing people.
- joshwa 19y agoIt's also a selection bias-- $5000+5000n effectively rules out most people who are farther along in life.
- ivankirigin 19y agoNo it doesn't. Further along also means financial resources or contacts that can make up the difference.
- michaelneale 19y agoIf you have financial resources - I guess you would only go to YC for the publicity ? The money would mean nothing.
- attack 19y agoNot everyone with a family to support has tons of money saved up so they can go without income for a year. Almost none do. I have no idea how you could possibly say "No it doesn't".
- ivankirigin 19y agoHe said "rules out". No it doesn't. It was an over generalization.
- attack 19y ago
- SwellJoe 19y agoMy co-founder has kids and is older than the OP, and we never felt like that had any impact on our acceptance to YC.
- mosburger 19y agoThat's good to know! From some of the comments around here, I was starting to feel a little like the guy who showed up at the party uninvited. I probably take things too personally. :)
- SwellJoe 19y agoJust to further reassure you, the average age of YC founders has been creeping upward from the beginning, and there have been many over-30 founders at this point. And, in many polls of age here on News.YC the range of ages run higher than you seem to think. Young single folks are just able to take dramatic risks that occasionally lead to dramatic success, and thus get a disproportionate amount of press. Older folks tend to have responsibilities and more experience which leads to taking fewer and more carefully calculated risks. Successes are less surprising and look more like traditional businesses...so you don't see them talked about as much. But businesses are being started by folks of all ages and a lot of those folks are here at News.YC.