5 ms·
There was a great piece whose identifying information I'm blanking on that explained how we stumbled into drone warfare. Basically, we tried doing snatch & gra
by patio11 16y ago
There was a great piece whose identifying information I'm blanking on that explained how we stumbled into drone warfare. Basically, we tried doing snatch & grabs with commando teams for a while, and that kept generating one negative externality we weren't willing to tolerate. Illegal acts? No. Media pressure? No. Collateral damage? No. Diplomatic reprecussions? No. Prisoners.
Prisoners are a real handful. What are our options? Let them go? Well, no gain there. Put a bullet in the back of their head? Americans won't go for it. Try them in a civilian court? You get to expose sources & methods, they might walk anyhow (evidence tends to be testimony of equally unsavory characters plus something classified to the nth degree and not worth burning on Mook #473), and the successful outcome is they go plot their next terrorist act from a federal penitentiary. Try them in military court? All the fun of a civilian court, and the New York Times editorial board will make it sound like you took the bullet option anyhow.
You know what has never once happened as a result of a Predator drone strike? A live prisoner in US custody.
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoInteresting anecdote: up until WWII or so, American commanders had little problem dealing with enemy noncombatants on the battlefield. There was a brief trial followed by an execution. Over time, the whole trial and such got to be counter-productive for the military, all that publicity and such. Warfare became much more a PR game. So commanders started emphasizing killing over capturing. This trend has nothing to do with the war on terror. Eisenhower back in WWII sent out memos to his commanders saying he didn't want to see a lot of snipers being captured. The implications were pretty clear. Drone warfare is just the continuation of this larger trend.
- ryanwaggoner 16y agoAmerican commanders had little problem dealing with enemy noncombatants on the battlefield. Did you mean combatants? Typically noncombatants would refer to medical personnel, chaplains, etc. It'd be interesting to know if people like this were routinely tried and executed.
- varjag 16y agoPerhaps he meant irregular combatants.
- gaius 16y agoNo, a chaplain in a military uniform is a combatant as far as the Geneva Convention is concerned, and must be treated as a POW. The term more recently used was "unlawful combatant".
- ryanwaggoner 16y agoThough the Geneva Conventions do not state whether chaplains may bear arms, they specify (Protocol I, 8 June 1977, Art 43.2) that chaplains are noncombatants. In recent years both the UK and US have required chaplains, but not medical personnel, to be unarmed. Other nations, notably Norway, Denmark and Sweden, make it an issue of individual conscience. Captured chaplains are not considered Prisoners of War (Third Convention, 12 August 1949, Chapter IV Art 33) and must be returned to their home nation unless retained to minister to prisoners of war. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaplain#Military http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaplain#Military
- gaius 16y agoI stand corrected :-) But the point still stands - a chaplain in uniform on the battlefield wouldn't be tried and executed at a drumhead.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI suspect he means "spies and saboteurs" (to borrow the language of geneva), i.e. combatants who don't display a distinctive sign recognizable at a distance and openly carry weapons. (The rationale: if one army can't tell the difference between civilians and soldiers, it puts civilians at greater risk. Thus, Geneva creates an incentive for not doing this.)
- adamc 16y agoGood movie dealing with this in the Boer War: Breaker Morant (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breaker_Morant_%28film%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breaker_Morant_%28film%29)
- rdtsc 16y ago> You know what has never once happened as a result of a Predator drone strike? A live prisoner in US custody. That makes a lot of sense. It is the optimal way of disposing of people on hidden black lists. The other upside for them -- Americans don't put their lives in danger, unless we consider driving to Langley in DC traffic every day as "danger". So they never have to deal with that PR aspect of the operation.
- krschultz 16y agoThat is entirely irrelevent. Dropping a bomb from a plane or a UAV is basically the same thing in these wars. The enemies have no weapons capable of shooting down our fighters. Have we lost a single plane to enemy SAMs in either Iraq or Afghanistan? We've certainly lost some helicopters, but there really is no difference between an F/18 and a Predator. If anything the UAV allows for more accuracy and a better view of the aftermath, the pilot of a manned plane is trying to get in and get out, the pilots of a UAV are watching before, during, and after the strike. The pilot of a manned fighter sees less of the actual attack and is even further removed. The same can be said for ships at sea firing Tomahawks, and before that artillery. Once you get beyond the face to face fighting of infantry it just becomes more and more abstract until we are here today where the guys pulling the trigger are 3,000 miles away.
- HeyLaughingBoy 16y agoI don't disagree with what you said, but the real abstraction is the ability to shoot and not be shot at. Even with "beyond the horizon" battles, two ships at sea are hitting each other. The difference between dying from a shell fired 20 miles away or one fired 1/2 mile away is nonexistent.
- runjake 16y agoMay I ask on what experience and evidence do you base all of your conclusions on? I assume you are or were a military pilot, or an analyst?