3 ms·
Government regulations. The SEC defines an accredited investor as a millionaire, or someone with income > $200k. Millionaires have access to investment opportun
by modeless 8y ago
Government regulations. The SEC defines an accredited investor as a millionaire, or someone with income > $200k. Millionaires have access to investment opportunities like this that are illegal to offer to non-millionaires. The logic is that millionaires are less likely to go broke because of a bad investment, but it does have a "rich get richer" effect.
- patio11 8y agoA slightly more optimistic take is that it's legal to offer this investment opportunity to non-millionaires. You have two choices: 1) Don't solicit publicly (i.e. don't make a business out of convincing non-affiliated retail investors to invest in Bitcoin; you can still band along with friends, family, and fools in a non-scalable fashion) 2) Do solicit publicly, but go through the disclosures-and-compliance process that society has decided should gate scalable access to retail investors' life savings The cryptocurrency economy is largely unwilling to do #2, which is onerous, expensive, and (ahem) exceedingly difficult to get through if you have produced nothing of economic substance.
- modeless 8y agoNo, it's not legal to offer this investment opportunity to non-millionaires, as the SEC has closed off your option #2. There have been several very serious efforts at regulatory compliance, involving big players in traditional finance, that have been rebuffed. Bitcoin index funds are not allowed to do public offerings right now, no matter how much compliance and disclosure they do. Not that I think it would be a great idea for anyone to sink their life savings into Bitcoin right now, but I think the SEC could do their job protecting investors without literally creating a 2-class system of rich privileged people and restricted poor people. For example, they could set limits on the percentage of your income or net worth you could invest in risky opportunities. That would allow people of all income levels to participate.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> it's not legal to offer this investment opportunity to non-millionaires right now Bitcoin futures are legal. The principal issue ETF sponsors are running into is constructing an index. The SEC isn't thrilled with indices referencing trades on e.g. Bitfinex.
- modeless 8y agoWe're not talking about Bitcoin futures. The investment opportunity under discussion here is an index fund.
- hyprCoin 8y agoA slightly more pessimistic view is that the rich part of society have engaged in regulatory capture to control the most profitable genesis events for their own mutual self interests. Looks a lot like class warfare on the poor/middle class and intelligent.
- Applejinx 8y agoThis is what dismays me. The notion of a crypto index fund seems horrible, in that cryptocurrencies are already such an abstraction of capital: first time it's been literally possible to turn energy into capital without benefiting any human in any way. That is very efficient and will drive out less efficient ways of generating capital. An index fund reduces the volatility of this and makes it even more of a given. If we must do this can we just make a rule that all ultra-rich people and only ultra-rich people automatically get 20% more riches a month, or week, or day, and NOT burn the impossibly huge amounts of energy that expanding cryptocurrency will incur? I am not at all sure it's possible to stop capital concentrating this way, but I do think it is peculiarly horrible to have it doing so by a mechanism that intentionally and pointlessly burns energy in an ever-increasing fashion, when we're already in serious trouble through our collective eagerness to burn energy.