8 ms·
It is indeed poor form but all you have to do is to follow the first link which will show you the one in question. It's sufficiently vile and inaccurate (the g
by hga 16y ago
It is indeed poor form but all you have to do is to follow the first link which will show you the one in question.
It's sufficiently vile and inaccurate (the guy's a small time Smalley who even ends his essay with a quote from that liar) that I can see why he refused to directly link to it. Plus since it's mostly a hand waving attempt to deny all of what Drexler has been saying, the author is not addressing the essay so much as pointing out why Drexler's proposition has never been tested (it's never been funded).
ADDED: On the other hand, I suppose all this is only fitting, given Drexler's belief back then that rational science policy was possible and his enthusiasm for mechanisms that would enable this. In the '70s and '80s there were clearly aspects of human nature he just couldn't wrap his head around.
- pierre_M 16y agoI've noticed that many non-scientists who have read Drexler seem to acquire a level of belief that has more in common with religion than science. Religious characteristics of this include: 1. Getting so angry about those who disagree with you that you can't even bring yourself to link to the thing you're supposedly rebutting 2. Using "Smalley" like it's a swear word. 3. A reversal of the usual burden of proof (Drexler likes to go on about how nothing he wrote has ever been proven wrong yet, but usually the onus lies on those who say something is technologically possible rather than those who say it isn't. 4. And of course, attributing a lack of success in proving their hypothesis to something somewhere between incompetence and conspiracy on the part of the scientific establishment. What I find most aggravating about the molecular nanotechnology folks, though, is that they're always complaining that research on MNT is underfunded and understaffed, but so rarely propose specific research projects that we could actually do. You think it's possible to build a universal assembler? Heck, I'm willing to entertain the idea. But how do we get there from here? What specific experiments and calculations can we start doing right now that can get us closer to that goal? I suspect that any answers to that question are likely to wind up looking like the "ordinary chemistry" which this MBA guy is so quick to deride.