4 ms·
Anyone have any good articles/books on why Greece has never reached greatness or similar status to other EU powers since the middle ages? Especially given their
by dmix 8y ago
Anyone have any good articles/books on why Greece has never reached greatness or similar status to other EU powers since the middle ages? Especially given their influence on the enlightenment, mathematics, philosophy, and Roman culture itself - which spread throughout the western world.
I've always been curious why they have stagnated so much since and been so... mediocre.
I guess you could say the same about Macedonia and maybe some middle eastern areas if we're looking purely at past greatness, but those two seem to be easier to explain. Greece's impact was more wider, longer, and stronger.
- xkcd-sucks 8y agoWe have a good life at low cost in our "mediocre" home, and travel to London/New York to do all that economically productive stuff that no sane person actually enjoys it is the next stage of civilizational evolution, look forward to it America :)
- dmix 8y ago> all that economically productive stuff that no sane person actually enjoys If that's the culture of modern greece then that explains a lot in itself. I guess the tentacles of socialism are still strangling Greece and it's legacy has been embedded in their culture [1]. > We have a good life at low cost Not to make this political but that lifestyle clearly hasn't exactly been sustainable and has been heavily subsidized externally AND internally. Which will cripple future growth for years to pay for yesterdays misteps. The fact all economically productive people leave to other places says as much about the anti-business enviornment present in Greece as much as it does about people's lifestyle choices there. No one wants to leave their hometown to make a living or do great things. It's always a consequence of trade-offs (ie, taxation, regulatory sanity, access to talented, hardworking, and educated people, excitement/apathy towards the future of the country, etc). [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2015/07/01/greek-disaster-is-all-about-socialism.html https://www.cnbc.com/2015/07/01/greek-disaster-is-all-about-...
- LfLxfxxLxfxx 8y agoplease, avoid abbreviating European as EU
- _dps 8y agoThe answer is simple, and sad. We (I am Greek) missed out on the Renaissance and the Enlightenment because we were under the boot of the Ottoman empire for 400 years. By the time we achieved freedom, we were a backwater too far behind everyone else in Europe to be competitive.
- dmix 8y agoInteresting, I'm sure there's multiple causes but that could certainly contribute significantly.
- asveikau 8y agoIsn't that somewhat the whole story of today's southern europe? The benefits of modernity probably means they live better than they ever did, but most southern european states are to some varying extent living in the shadow of former glory. Perhaps a lesson in the gap between economics and worthiness or merit.
- djif 8y ago> I guess you could say the same about Macedonia and maybe some middle eastern areas if we're looking purely at past greatness, but those two seem to be easier to explain. Greece's impact was more wider, longer, and stronger. Just a correction - Macedonia was (and is) part of Greece: https://history.stackexchange.com/questions/6265/was-alexander-the-great-greek-or-macedonian https://history.stackexchange.com/questions/6265/was-alexand...
- dmix 8y agoI didn't know Alexander and the Macedon's were ethnically Greek. That makes more sense now given their accomplishments in that era. Thanks for the link.