3 ms·
Something like this would certainly have helped me during high school and university, but I suspect schools may view it as competing against themselves by showi
by nitrogen 16y ago
Something like this would certainly have helped me during high school and university, but I suspect schools may view it as competing against themselves by showing students all they need to know, thus allowing them to skip school and learn the exact same material on their own.
- xyzzyz 16y agoWhat is the problem with students skipping classes and learning the material on their own? If they like it more that way and have good results, why should they be forced to attend the classes they do not like, or do not find helpful in absorbing the material? Universities are supposed to do the research and help students learn things. If the students learn things and scientists do research, everything is all right, I guess. No need to impose a military regime. However, it might not be true for high schools, for it is more supposed to gather students in one place and keep them from fooling around, than actually teaching them stuff.
- jseliger 16y agoI suspect schools may view it as competing against themselves This kind of thought process is strange to my way of thinking but plausible; very few teachers I ever had said, "Hey, this is why we're doing what we're doing and why it's important," which is part of the reason I make a point of saying exactly that in the classes I teach. One favorite question: "Why are we reading this, as opposed to something else? What are you supposed to take from it?" by showing students all they need to know, thus allowing them to skip school and learn the exact same material on their own. This seems implausible: if students came in already well-prepared or overly advanced for the classes I teach (chiefly Engl composition), I'd be delighted. By now I've taught about ~250 students, and somewhere between 1 and 6 haven't really needed a comp class. Probably only 1. But I can guarantee that more than 6 have thought they didn't need a comp class... HN has a lot of talk about being self-motivated, and learning on your own, and so forth, which I think is great. But standing in front of a classroom makes me think that the number of people who will really do this is not very great, especially without deadlines and so forth to motivate them (for more on this, see Dan Ariely's book _Predictably Irrational_). That's not to say the number of very self-motivated people who could acquire the knowledge that school imparts on their own is zero. It isn't. But it's really, really small, which is part of the reason school systems are shaped as they are.
- scott_s 16y agoThis reasoning doesn't hold up because all of the information is already available through course descriptions and syllabi on course webpages. You don't even need to attend a school to get at that information.