3 ms·
Why the quotes? EU itself refers to this as copyright reform[0]. I assume they know what's in their own directive. There are a lot of reasons why this is a bad
by danShumway 8y ago
Why the quotes? EU itself refers to this as copyright reform[0]. I assume they know what's in their own directive.
There are a lot of reasons why this is a bad idea, but just looking at precedent alone should be enough to give people pause.
Germany already introduced a link tax 4 years ago. Google just stopped showing link snippets for publishers, publishers realized their click-through rates from search results were a lot worse without snippets, and most of them gave Google free licenses to include the snippets. It was a complete failure. Ironically, a law that was intended to stop Google from gobbling up more ad revenue created a situation where Google's position was even more entrenched, because they were free to continue operating as normal and small sites weren't.
The upload filter is problematic because it's an automated upload filter that would be required by law to preserve safe havens, would have zero consideration for fair use, would have no real penalties for misuse by bad actors, and would serve as precedent for whatever the next thing is that lawmakers decide to block.
But again, skipping all of that we also have data on upload filters, ie Youtube's content ID, which is regularly abused by bad actors to remove fair-use content, troll and attack activists, and censor criticism. Creatives and small publishers hate content ID.
I have a fair amount of respect for EU lawmakers for often taking experimental approaches to laws where they'll do limited trials or gather data to get a more educated understanding of what a policy will do. Ignoring any of the common sense problems with the proposal, it's kind of crazy to me that any of this is still on the table when there are zero practical examples of link taxes or upload filters actually working in the real world.
[0]: https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market/en/modernisation-eu-copyright-rules https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market/en/modernisation-...