4 ms·
Not nearly cynical enough. A lot of the things written here are sort of the 'ideal'. The fact of the matter is, if you want to be a chemist, you probably shou
by dnautics 16y ago
Not nearly cynical enough. A lot of the things written here are sort of the 'ideal'. The fact of the matter is, if you want to be a chemist, you probably shouldn't be anything but a chemistry major (or something related enough, or effectively complete the chemistry reqs). I don't know that colleges are 'places where knowledge is created'. In retrospect, I feel like colleges are places where people get that A (i.e. a college diploma) to prove they've been there - and to gain qualifiaction in the eyes of the outside world.
Whether or not that should be the case, that seems to be the way that it is.
The Paul Krugman quote is shudder-worthy, but that is a personal bias.
- barrkel 16y agoRe creating knowledge, it depends on the specialism. In a lot of computer science, I feel that university is perhaps one third ad-hoc / industrial trends and practices getting formalized; one third blue skies work of a some relevance, though by the time it becomes relevant is quickly overtaken by industry; and one third useless formalizations generation, more exercises in rigour (or not) for their formulators than measurable knowledge.
- dnautics 16y ago...It actually probably more depends on the school. To a certain degree there are computer science programs where the net result is large-scale training in collaborative development. At the university where I worked, there was a graduate CS class where over the course of 10 weeks they rewrote the transportation department's website (enabling real-time tracking of campus busses and wi-fi base stations in all the busses). However, I was a chemistry/math major as an undergrad, at a primarily research institution. I imagine chemistry departments at primarily undergrad institutions were probably not as involved in the process of "knowledge creation" - that's what REUs were for - and who can say about the humanities and political science?