8 ms·
Instead of Maine, you can find a better analogy at the opposite end of the United States. There’s a Mexican state named Baja California and a US state named si
by pavlov 8y ago
Instead of Maine, you can find a better analogy at the opposite end of the United States.
There’s a Mexican state named Baja California and a US state named simply California. Exact same thing as this Macedonia business.
- baron816 8y agoThere’s also a state north of Mexico called New Mexico.
- labster 8y agoThat state was named in the 1500s by Spanish explorers. If it was a political name at all, it was probably in reference to Aztlan and Mexican politics.
- rspeer 8y agoThere's a province of Indonesia named Papua, on the island of New Guinea, bordering the country Papua New Guinea. I have no idea what the inhabitants think about this or if anyone even cares, but it sounds quite confusing.
- pwinnski 8y agoExcept the "Baja" in this case (or its lack in the USA) is like the compromise, "North" Macedonia. The situations would be more analogous if the Mexican state were called simply "California" or the US state were called "Baja California."
- pavlov 8y agoIn both cases, the bigger and more powerful side got to keep the plain name and the other side had to settle for a geographic prefix.
- pwinnski 8y agoAs I understand it, both sides had prefixes: Baja and Alta. After the US took Alta California, they dropped that prefix. Mexico was never forced to add one.
- pavlov 8y agoThey dropped the prefix because Mexico wasn't in a position to object. I wouldn't be surprised if many expected at the time that the newly founded US state would annex Baja eventually.
- SamReidHughes 8y agoWe had that opportunity -- the guy negotiating the treaty decided San Diego was far enough.
- s_trumpet 8y agocounterpoint: the Indian state of West Bengal and the country of Bangladesh (lit. Land of the Bengali).
- DrScump 8y agoThe Baja peninsula includes two separate Mexican states: Baja California and Baja California Sur.
- forinti 8y agoI think this analogy shows that names don't really matter: military superiority does.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- na85 8y ago"Might makes right" is not a new concept.
- labster 8y agoNot really correct. The peninsula consists of two Mexican states: Baja California Sur, and Baja California Norte. The United States dropped the "Alta" from Alta California after the process of defeating Mexico. I consider us all Californians, though, despite the political boundaries.
- pavlov 8y agoMaybe the previously-Alta California should follow the Mexican example and split into separate north and south states? That would fix issues with federal political representation, at least.
- macintux 8y agoGiven its population, California (U.S.) could and arguably should split into several states. An even division into 5 states would still leave them around the size of Washington.
- labster 8y agoAs soon as anyone explains how water would be apportioned in the new system, I might consider it.
- DrScump 8y agoBaja California Norte No, just Baja California, or officially, the "Free and Sovereign State of Baja California" (Spanish: Estado Libre y Soberano de Baja California), according to its Wikipedia entry.
- dghughes 8y agoI know this is always unpopular but, how about the name America? I refer to the country south of me as "the US" or "the USA". To me as a Canadian I live in the Americas so I could be an American. Growing up nobody I knew called the US "America" you'd even hear "the Boston States", I have no clue how that originated. But I've noticed over the past decade or two it's become more common for people in the US to refer to their country as America. I know it's a shortened form but still, to me, it's weird because: Europe, Europeans Africa, Africans Asia, Asians Americas, ? (demonym for people of the entire region?) I know some people counter with it's "North America dummy!" but wouldn't that mean the USA should be the USNA?
- russellbeattie 8y agoThe terms America and Americans have been used for hundreds of years, not just the last decade or two. I've had this same conversation with Mexicans and people from South America. The U.S. was the first independent country in the Americas recognized by foreign countries and remained the only one for many years. The term American had been used by the British for years to refer to the colonies, and was adopted by the country itself. In his farewell address, George Washington said this: "The name of American, which belongs to you in your national capacity, must always exalt the just pride of patriotism more than any appellation." More than that, this is just what citizens of the U.S. are called. New Zealanders are Kiwis and Brits are Brits and Canadians are Canadians. Every nationality has a name, this is ours. The continents shouldn't be called America anyways, as Amerigo Vespuci had little to do with its discovery or exploration, but that's the way it is. In other words, this isn't some evil American power grab, and an insult to the rest of our Western Hemisphere neighbors, but a quirk of history that won't change any time soon.
- dgut 8y agoIt's irrelevant what Washington or anybody else said. The common name for the North and South American landmasses is America (note: not Americas). The land between Canada and Mexico has no more rights to that name than the rest of the continent (or continents, depending on what model you prefer). Abroad, Hollywood has popularized the use of "American" to refer to citizens of the USA. Also, most languages don't have any other way to refer to US citizens because of its odd name. I'm only aware of Spanish "estadounidenses". It's no different than if the most powerful European country were to call themselves Europeans alone.