3 ms·
I think it's a bit more complex and gray-area when you need a model release, even for commercial publications. The canonical "need one" example is using someone
by _delirium 16y ago
I think it's a bit more complex and gray-area when you need a model release, even for commercial publications. The canonical "need one" example is using someone's likeness on a billboard to sell products, or on the label of your product. The canonical "don't need one, even if use is commercial" example is newspapers publishing photographs taken in a public place as part of an article. For example, you don't need a protester's permission to publish a photo of them at a rally, even if your newspaper/magazine sells ads and is for profit.
There's a lot of in-between area, though. This site doesn't seem to be clearly using the photos in the model/advertising sort of way; they're not using them to launch a line of public-transit-rider products or putting them on tshirts or something. It's definitely a step down from journalistic reporting, but I could see it arguably falling closer to that than to the usual cases where model releases are needed. You could imagine a genuine reporter running a story on fashion trends in different demographics or something, illustrated by a few photos taken out in public, and this is basically the half-assed, mean-spirited tabloid version of that focusing on one particular demographic.
(Though as far as AdSense in particular goes, Google can of course make up any rules they want.)
- carbocation 16y agoYou don't see newspapers vindictively replacing all of their content except ads with a humiliating photo and a mocking, false story about their subject.
- _delirium 16y agoI agree, but that's more a question of whether it's valuable/interesting/trashy than a question of whether it's promotional modeling use, isn't it? This just doesn't look like the kind of uses that model releases are normally required for.
- kjuhjk 16y agoYou generally, at least in the USA and UK CAN use a person photo for commercial use without their consent - otherwise crowd shots of a game would be impossible, The only limitation is that you cannot imply they endorse a product unless they do. Even then a shot of them actually using a product - a celebrity with a can of your soda in their hand, would be acceptable as reportage.