4 ms·
It good to see a focus on weightlifting, and I'm glad to see that research like this is proving the same sort of benefit. It seems as though it's kind of faux
by SketchySeaBeast 8y ago
It good to see a focus on weightlifting, and I'm glad to see that research like this is proving the same sort of benefit. It seems as though it's kind of faux pas to focus on strength when other options like cardio are available. The standard for physical excellence these days has become the marathon, triathlon, or iron man, where I think that a long term focus on strength training is it's own unique reward, and it's own unique challenge, taking years and years of hard work and focused dedication to achieve peak performance, as opposed to a marathon where (a quick google says) one can achieve with 20 weeks of training.
- faitswulff 8y agoIt seems like a false distinction to me? Sure, you can complete a marathon in 20 weeks of training, but you can also squat a barbell on your first try at the gym. As someone who has done both, you can dedicate years to the pursuit of either practice. Either way, you will likely be better off. But I will agree that more research on the health benefits of casual strength training is always welcome.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoYou're absolutely right, it's a bit of a false distinction, and there are years of benefits one can see in either discipline. I just find that with strength there are obvious aesthetic changes for years, it seems to offer its most visible rewards on a much longer timeline.
- cwbrandsma 8y agoI've had arthritis in my knees since I was 18. All those running things just ain't happening. But I can lift. Lifting helped me get thru a pretty bad case of burn out.
- dingaling 8y agoSwimming is also excellent exercise with arthritis though for knees you would avoid breaststroke. It gives a cardio workout rather than just strength training.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- beat 8y agoLifting is the best thing I ever did for my damaged, pre-arthritic knees. Most of the suffering is probably not from the cartilage, but rather from weak muscles and tendons. Strengthen those, improve knee function, and the effects of arthritis are greatly reduced, in my own experience.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoIt's the exact same thing as people with bad backs. Bed rest may help the acute injury, but the best solution is to strengthen the problem area, not let it atrophy.
- x0x0 8y agoStrongman also provides a fun mix (high strength demands, but with cardio). Eg Húsafell / shield carries, frame carries, farmers, farmer medleys, etc. A 400lb pick isn't much, but carry it 300 feet and oof.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoStrongman is an incredibly impressive discipline. The energy one can expend in 30 seconds is just awesome.
- dayvid 8y agoI only ran long distance for a while and currently do weightlifting. All exercise is good for depression, but there's a definite psychological difference from lifting heavy weights. I feel more confident when I weightlift regularly. It feels good to be strong and fills something primal in me that running didn't necessarily do. Especially when you're actively resisting and pushing against something heavy. It's like battling an opponent.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoIt's an extraordinarily unique mental exercise to fight HARD for 30 seconds, to put the bar on your back and immediately start to panic from the weight pulling you down, and to push through that and squat down, feeling the whole time like you're going to get crushed, only to push back up, as hard as you can, and get to the top, and then realize you have to do it another 4 times. Undergoing that level of acute hardship on a regular basis gives one a different type of confidence, and changes how one sees the every day struggles one goes through.
- goldenkey 8y agoI can't for the life of me understand the mentality that would prefer a long exhausting run compared to 6 or so reps of a heavy weight until failure, for three sets, finished in 5 minutes. Running makes me feel like I'm gonna die. Weightlifting makes me feel like that only with extremely powerful lifts like doing squats. Can you explain why you prefer to draw out the discomfort rather than ripping the bandaid off immediately?
- DrScump 8y agoIt's not an either/or. Both have different, if complementary, effects. Each primarily activates different muscle fiber types, each with its own metabolic benefits.