4 ms·
I don't quite understand the negativity. Everyone complains about how IoT devices are a security nightmare because manufacturers don't update the software. No
by jrockway 8y ago
I don't quite understand the negativity. Everyone complains about how IoT devices are a security nightmare because manufacturers don't update the software. Now you are paying the ongoing cost to get that engineering done.
You could pay upfront, and many people do (that's what "enterprise" is and why it's $2000 for a $200 router)... but now the price of ongoing support is in reach of the average customer. (But they're mad that ongoing support is actually expensive.)
Now of course, if they do the same half-ass job that other router manufacturers do with ongoing support, the subscription fee won't be worth it. But if the product does continually improve relative to other offerings, then maybe it's the right business model.
Anyway, it is pure honesty to split out the hardware cost and the software engineering cost. The question is whether or not it's actually worthwhile to pay the software engineering cost. It's a pretty new idea, and there are plenty of reasons to not trust it... but in theory, I like it.
- Bud 8y agoThe negativity is easy to understand. Somehow, Apple managed to sell routers for 20 years, and keep them updated for over a decade after purchase, without charging exorbitant fees for routine software updates. How did they manage that? They didn't do it in a "halfass" way, either.
- jrockway 8y agoHow sustainable a business was that, though? Obviously it was not making them huge amounts of money, because they stopped doing it.
- sandworm101 8y agoYou want your home network to be remotely managed? Good routers are cheap. Dirt cheap. With a little bit of knowledge anyone can maintain a secure and stable wifi network. The potential privacy and security downsides of outsourcing this task far outweigh the inconvenience. If you really want to throw money at a wifi problem, invest in some actual diagnostics hardware. An ubertooth (100$) and monitor mode-capable wifi dongle (50$) will teach you more than a thousand Plume adverts.
- AlexandrB 8y ago> I don't quite understand the negativity. Everyone complains about how IoT devices are a security nightmare because manufacturers don't update the software. Now you are paying the ongoing cost to get that engineering done. The incentives here are extremely perverse. The problem of insecure IoT gear was in many cases created by manufacturers cutting corners. Now they offer to fix it for money. It should not have been acceptable in the first place! To use a car analogy - car manufacturers are compelled by regulation to do recalls on defects that impact the safety of a vehicle. They don't get to charge a monthly subscription to resolve their own mistakes. I'm not sure why we let tech companies get away with abusing their customers like this.