3 ms·
The government should do precisely NOTHING. Exactly. It is not the job of the State to make sure everybody has a job. Arguably all the State should do is prote
by mindcrime 8y ago
The government should do precisely NOTHING.
Exactly. It is not the job of the State to make sure everybody has a job. Arguably all the State should do is protect property rights, enforce contracts and provide some notion of a "justice system". And really, all three of those things can be debated.
The best way to think of it, IMO, is the way Bastiat[1] put it by describing "the law" as "no more than the collective extension to our individual right to self defense". (paraphrased slightly).
[1]: http://bastiat.org/en/the_law.html http://bastiat.org/en/the_law.html
- chongli 8y agoThe job of the state, ultimately, is to preserve itself. In practice, that means upholding a social contract in order to maintain order. If we see a widespread outbreak of technological unemployment then more effort on the part of government is necessary lest public order breaks down. It's that simple. No moral arguments are necessary.
- mindcrime 8y agoWidespread technological unemployment is definitely a concern, no question there. I'm just not convinced that government is the best tool to try and solve that problem, on both moral and practical grounds. But when I say "government" I really mean "Government as we know it today" - big, corrupt, invasive, inefficient, etc. Possibly a better model could be developed which would be better suited. That, to me, is the challenge for our time.
- chongli 8y agoI don't see government corruption as being wholly determined by models. Models are a factor, no doubt, and you can affect the rate at which corruption encroaches by changing the model, but time and complexity are also major factors. Within a given model, complexity tends to increase with time and thus so does corruption. Perhaps another way to look at it is just to consider corruption as one form of complexity. Eventually complexity increases beyond the point of diminishing returns into negative territory. Then the system collapses. This is the position of Joseph Tainter, one I find particularly compelling.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- RobertoG 8y agoThe state not only protect property rights, it defines them.
- moate 8y agoThe problem is that when you have a recently minted, largely unemployed underclass who are not having their basic needs met, you frequently get rebellion. At that point the state's ability to enforce contracts, protect property, and dole out justice becomes severely hampered. The best way to think of it, IMO, is the way Marx described the State which is a group built to protect the bourgeoisie. It should (will? could?) eventually reach a point in which the State represents a social contract between all members of a civil society to work in the group's overall best interests.
- mindcrime 8y agoThe best way to think of it, IMO, is the way Marx described the State which is a group built to protect the bourgeoisie. It's funny, I've got a whole pile of books by, and on, Marx, piled up waiting to be read (even though I'm a Libertarian in American terms. "know thy enemy" and all that) but finding time to get to that stuff is always the challenge. I did not realize that Marx described the State as such. That is a somewhat interesting take on things.
- moate 8y agoThe basics of the most Marxism and Conflict Theory are that 1- There is an imbalance in the availability of goods/services relative to needs/desires (capitalists call this "supply and demand"). 2- Society is built in such a way that those bourgeoisie are rewarded unfairly for their contribution (ownership and capital) relative to the contributions of the proletariat(physical creation of goods, performance of service) 3- The current state exists in ways that allow for that status quo to continue, through the very existence of a "State Class" (politicians) who act on behalf of the Owner Class but create the illusion of a second group acting against the workers thus dividing their attention